CONTESTED CASE MATERIALS for DLNR File No. CCH-LD-01
Posted on Nov 29, 2021 in CasesCONTESTED CASE MATERIALS for DLNR File No. CCH-LD-01
In the Matter of a Contested Case Regarding the Continuation of Revocable Permits (RPs) for Tax Map Key Nos. (2) 1-1-001:044 & 050; (2) 2-9-014:001, 005, 011, 012 & 017; (2) 1-1-002:002 (por.) and (2) 1-2-004:005 & 007 for Water Use on the Island of Maui to Alexander & Baldwin, Inc. (A&B) and East Maui Irrigation Company, LLC (EMI) for the remainder of the 2021 RPs, if applicable, and for their continuation through the end of 2022
Docket
- 2021-09-23_Disclosure of Hearings Officer; COS.PDF
- 2021-09-23_MINUTE ORDER No. 1; COS — [Appointing Hr’g Officer].pdf
- 2021-09-27_Sierra Club — MOTION for Essential Info.pdf
- 2021-09-29_MINUTE ORDER No. 2, COS — [Amending Caption].PDF
- 2021-10-01_MINUTE ORDER No. 3, COS — [Briefing Sched RE – Mot for Essential Info (9-27-21)].PDF
- 2021-10-07_A&B.EMI — Opposition [RE – Mot for Essential Info (9-27-21)].pdf
- 2021-10-11_MINUTE ORDER No. 4, COS — [Setting Pre-Hr’g Conference].pdf
- 2021-10-11_Sierra Club — Reply [RE – Mot. for Essential Info (9-27-21)].pdf
- 2021-10-14_Sierra Club — MOTION for a Court Reporter.pdf
- 2021-10-17_MINUTE ORDER No. 5, COS — [Denying – Mot for Court Reporter (10-14-21)].PDF
- 2021-10-21_COM — MOTION-Application to Intervene as Party.pdf
- 2021-10-28_MINUTE ORDER No. 6; COS — [Setting Hr’g RE – Maui Intervention (10-21-21)].PDF
- 2021-10-29_A&B.EMI — Joinder [RE – Maui Intervention (10-21-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-01_MINUTE ORDER No. 7; COS — [Denying – Mot. for Essential Info (9-27-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-01_Sierra Club — Opposition [RE – Maui Intervention (10-21-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-05_COM — Reply [in Supp. RE – Maui Intervention (10-21-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-05_MINUTE ORDER No. 8; COS — [Setting Pre-Hr’g Deadlines].PDF
- 2021-11-12_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hr’g Filing — COS for all filings.pdf
- 2021-11-12_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hr’g Filing — EXHIBIT LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-12_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hr’g Filing — OPENING BRIEF.pdf
- 2021-11-12_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hr’g Filing — WITNESS LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-12_MINUTE ORDER No. 9; COS — [Errata RE – Minute Order No. 8 (11-5-21)].PDF
- 2021-11-15_MINUTE ORDER No. 10; COS — [Granting – Maui Intervention (10-21-21)].PDF
- 2021-11-15_Sierra Club — MOTION Asking BLNR to fulfill Trust Duties.pdf
- 2021-11-22_COM — Pre-Hr’g Filing — EXHIBIT LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-22_COM — Pre-Hr’g Filing — OPENING BRIEF.pdf
- 2021-11-22_COM — Pre-Hr’g Filing — WITNESS LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-22_Sierra Club — REQUEST for Subpoena – Wilson Okamoto.pdf
- 2021-11-23_Errata to Declaration of Ceil Howe, III.pdf
- 2021-11-24_A&B.EMI — REQUEST for Subpoena – Ayron Strauch.pdf
- 2021-11-24_MINUTE ORDER No. 11; COS — [Denying – Mot to fulfill Trust Duties (11-15-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-24_MINUTE ORDER No. 12; COS — [Denying – Req for Subpoena (11-22-21)].pdf
- 2021-11-29_Sierra Club — Pre-Hr’g Filing — EXHIBIT LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-29_Sierra Club — Pre-Hr’g Filing — RESPONSIVE BRIEF.pdf
- 2021-11-29_Sierra Club — Pre-Hr’g Filing — WITNESS LIST.pdf
- 2021-11-29_Sierra Club — REQUEST for Subpoena, 2nd – 5x DLNR Staff (Fretz, Hirokawa, Hau, Manuel, Strauch).pdf
- 2021-11-29_Sierra Club — REQUEST for Subpoena, 2nd – Wilson Okamoto.pdf
- 2021-11-30_MINUTE ORDER No. 13; COS — [Notice of Hearing Dates, Etc].pdf
- 2021-12-02_Sierra Club — MOTION re recording.pdf
- 2021-12-03_MINUTE ORDER No 14; COS — [subpoenas, etc].pdf
- 2021-12-03_MINUTE ORDER No. 15; COS — [Denying – Req for Recording (12-02-21)].pdf
- 2021-12-06_A&B.EMI — COS — [Strauch Subpoena ROS].pdf
- 2021-12-06_A&B.EMI — ROS & Acknowledgement — RE Strauch Subpoena (signed 12-03-21).pdf
- 2021-12-06_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hrg Filing — REPLY BRIEF.pdf
- 2021-12-06_A&B.EMI — Pre-Hrg Filing — Updated Exhibit List.pdf
- 2021-12-06_COM — Pre-Hrg Filing — REPLY BRIEF.pdf
- 2021-12-07_Sierra Club — MOTION to Open Hearing.pdf
- 2021-12-07_MINUTE ORDER No. 16; COS — [Denying – SCs Mot. to Open Hrg filed 12-7-21].pdf
- 2021-12-07_MINUTE ORDER No. 17; COS — [Notice of Webpage].pdf
- 2021-12-08_MINUTE ORDER No 18; COS — [Further HRS 91-9 Notice].pdf
- 2021-12-10 COMs First Amd Exhibit List.pdf
- 2021-12-14_Sierra Club — EXHIBIT LIST (Amended).pdf
- 2021-12-21_COM — Post-Hrg Filing — (Proposed) FOF-COL.pdf
- 2021-12-22_A&B_EMI Proposed FOF_COL.pdf
- 2021-12-22_Proposed FOF COL Sierra Club.pdf
- 2022-04-26_HEARING OFFICER’S Proposed FOF-COL and Decision & Order.pdf
- 2022-04-27_MINUTE ORDER No. 19; COS – [exceptions to be filed by 5-13-22].pdf
- 2022-04-28_Sierra Club – Motion for Preparation of Hearing Transcript
- 2022-04-28_Sierra Club – Motion to Recuse Suzanne Case
- 2022-05-02_MINUTE ORDER No. 20; COS – [respond to 2x motions by 5-6-22]
- 2022-05-03_Sierra Club – Motion to Re-Open Hearing
- 2022-05-05_MINUTE ORDER No. 21; COS – [respond to mot. to re-open by 5-9-22]
- 2022-05-09_A&B.EMI – Position Statement re Mot. to Re-Open.pdf
- 2022-05-09_Sierra Club – Reply to 3x Motions.pdf
- 2022-05-11_MINUTE ORDER No. 22 – setting oral argument.pdf
- 2022-05-12 _MINUTE ORDER No. 23-transcripts and reopening
- 2022-05-13_COM Statement of No Exceptions to HO FOF.pdf
- 2022-05-13_MINUTE ORDER No. 24 — Denying Motion to Recuse Case.PDF
- 2022-05-13_MINUTE ORDER No. 25 — Denying Motion for Transcript, Granting Motion to Reopen.PDF
- 2022-05-16_Sierra Club — 2nd MOTION re Matters Outside the Record.pdf
- 2022-05-16_A&B Exceptions to FOF, COL.pdf
- 2022-05-16_SC Exceptions to FOF, COL.pdf
- 2022-05-18_SC Response to A&B Exceptions.PDF
- 2022-05-18_COM Response to SC Exception.PDF
- 2022-05-18_A&B Repsonses to SC Exceptions.PDF
- 2022-05-27_Minute Order No 26 Re-Setting Oral Arguments.PDF
- 2022-06-01 Closing Argument Transcript.pdf
- 2022-06-03_SC Motion to Supplement Record.PDF
- 2022-06-07_ Minute Order No. 27 Motion to Supplement Record Denied.PDF
- 2022-06-30_FOF, COL and Decision & Order.PDF
- 2022-07-11_Errata to FOF, COL and D&O.PDF
Witnesses
Exhibits
Audio Recordings of Hearing
- 12/8/2021: audio recording
- 12/9/2021: audio recording
- 12/13/2021: audio recording
- 12/14/2021: audio recording
- 12/15/2021: audio recording
Electronically Generated Transcriptions of the Hearing
These electronically generated transcriptions are provided only to aid in navigating the audio recordings and are not intended to be part of the official record of the contested case, nor are they intended to be cited by the parties. They have not been checked for accuracy. Unless or until otherwise noted, the audio recordings constitute the official record of the contested case hearing.
- 12/8/2021: transcription
- 12/9/2021: transcription
- 12/13/201: transcription
- 12/14/2021: transcription
- 12/15/2021: transcription