Documents Library

Document Library for Contested Case HA-16-02 regarding Conservation District Use Application (CDUA) HA-3568 for the Thirty Meter Telescope at the Mauna Kea Science Reserve, Kaohe Mauka, Hamakua District, Hawaii, TMK (3) 4-4-015:009

These documents are provided for informational purposes only.  They do not constitute the official record of the contested case.  The official record is located at the DLNR Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, 1151 Punchbowl Street, #131, Honolulu, Hawaii 96813.

Note: The Record in the contested case is now closed, pursuant to Minute Order No. 102 filed on July 25, 2017.

Doc. No. Date filedFiled byContested Case HA-16-02
78428-Jul-17BLNRMinute Order No. 103, Order regarding filing exceptions to Hearing Officer's recommendations and setting oral arguments on exceptions; COS
78326-Jul-17Hearing OfficerHearing Officer's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law and Decision and Order; COS
78225-Jul-17102 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 102: Declaration Record Closed; COS
78124-Jul-17101 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 101, Order denying Cindy Freitas motion to admit exhibits out of time (Doc. 760); COS
78021-Jul-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to The University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position re: Harry Fergerstrom's depraved indifference [Doc. 776] and collusion to skirt the law [Doc. 777] filings dated July 21, 2017; COS
77921-Jul-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position re: Harry Fergerstrom's depraved indifference [Doc. 776] and collusion to skirt the law [Doc. 777] filings; COS
77819-Jul-17C FreitasCindy Freitas joinder to Fergerstrom collusion to skirt the law; COS
77719-Jul-17FergerstromCollusion to skirt the law; Memorandum of support; COS
77618-Jul-17FergerstromDepraved indifference; Memorandum of support; COS
77517-Jul-1796 Minute Order amendedAmended Minute Order No. 96, Order denying Flores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 85 (Doc. 752): COS
77417-Jul-17100 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 100, Order re: second no-decisions for non-motion submissions (Docs. Nos. 141, 143, 188, 190, 225, 231, 248, 252, 279, 280, 285, 287, 288, 331, 339, 398, 400, 401, 412, 413); COS
77315-Jul-1799 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 99, Order rescinding Minute Order No. 90 denying Flores-Case Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence (Doc. 676); COS
77215-Jul-1798 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 98, Order denying Flores-Case Ohana's motion for clarification or, in the alternative reconsideration re: Minute Orders No. 43 and 44, filed 4/15/17 & 4/27/17 [Doc. Nos. 558 & 577] (Doc 634); COS
77114-Jul-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory’s opposition to Cindy Freitas’ motion to admit exhibits out of time dated July 10, 2017; [Doc. No. 760]; COS
77014-Jul-17 TIOTMT International Observatory’s opposition to Cindy Freitas’ motion to admit exhibits out of time dated July 10, 2017; COS
76914-Jul-1797 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 97, Order denying requests for continuances and next hearing date (Docs. Nos. 89, 90, 91, 92)
76814-Jul-1796 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 96, Order denying Flores-Case 'Ohana motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 85 (Doc. 752)
76714-Jul-1795 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 95, Order denying Cindy Freitas' motion to amend Doc 274 site visit to include request in Doc 220 (Doc. 278)
76614-Jul-1794 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 94, Order denying William Freitas' motion to amend Doc 274 site visit to include areas proposed in Doc 214 (Doc. 277)
76514-Jul-1793 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 93, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order 57 (Doc 694)
76413-Jul-1792 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 92, Order denying Cindy Freitas' motion to file motion out of time (Doc. 227)
76313-Jul-1791 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 91, Order denying Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 53 (Doc. 675)
76213-Jul-1790 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 90, Order denying Flores-Case Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence (Doc. 676)
76111-Jul-17ChingClarence Kukaukakahi Ching's joinder to Cindy Freitas motion to admit exhibits out of time; Memorandum in support of motion and exhibits "A," "B," and "C" files as document 760 on July 10, 2017; COS
76010-Jul-17C FreitasCindy Freitas motion to admit exhibits out of time; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
75910-Jul-1789 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 89, Order denying Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 49, filed May 20, 2017 [Doc. 643], and related documents [Doc. 652, 653]; Exhibit "A"; COS
75810-Jul-1788 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 88, Order denying Temple of Lono's motion to vacate Minute Order No. 39, or alternatively to partially reconsider Minute Order No. 39, filed November 6, 2016 [Doc. 409], and related document [Doc. 417]; COS
75730-Jun-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Flores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute order No. 85 [Doc. 752]; COS
75630-Jun-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Flores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute order No. 85 [Doc. 752]; COS
75529-Jun-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's joinder to Flores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 85 and memorandum of support of motion (Document No. 752); COS
75429-Jun-17LonoTemple of Lono change of address
75325-Jun-17C FreitasCindy Freitas joinder to Flores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 85; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
75224-Jun-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 85; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
75123-Jun-1787 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 87, Order denying Temple of Lono's motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568, filed March 25, 2017 [Doc. 516] and related documents [Doc. 518, 525, 549]; COS
75023-Jun-1786 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 86, Order denying TMT International Observatory, LLC's request for Board to act upon denial of intervention pursuant to HAR §13-1-31(G), filed August 26, 2016 [Doc. 246]; COS
74920-Jun-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position on Flores-Case Ohana's motion for clarification or, in the alternative, reconsideration re: Minute Orders No. 43 and 44, filed 4/25/17 & 4/27/17 (Doc. Nos. 58 & 57); Declaration of Counsel; COS
74817-Jun*1785 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 85, Order denying Flores-Case Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence (Doc. 676)
74715-Jun-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 57; COS
74615-Jun-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 57; COS
74515-Jun-1784 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 84, Order denying William Freitas, pro-se, filed William Freitas's motion to amend second witness list (Doc. 166) to include William Freitas as additional witness list to contested case hearing (Doc. 300) ("Motion") (Doc. 691); COS
74414-Jun-17Kahea Kahea: The Environmental Alliances joinder in Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, K. Pisciotta, D. Ward, P. Neves, K. Kanaele, L. Sleightholm, B. Kealoha, C. Freitas, M. Kihoi response to UHH / TIO proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order filed on June 13; COS
74314-Jun-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliances joinder in William Freitas response in opposition to University of Hilo and TMT International Observatory LLC's joint [proposed] Finding of Facts, Conclusions of Law and Decision & Order filed on June 13; COS
74214-Jun-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliances joinder in J. Leinaala Sleightholm's response to UHH and TIO's joint Finding's of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and proposed Decision and Order filed on June 13; COS
74114-Jun-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliances joinder in Clarence Kukauakahi Ching's responses to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint (proposed) Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order filed on June 13; COS
74014-Jun-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliances joinder in Flores-Case Ohana's response to UHH and TIO's joint proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision Order [Doc. No. 671] filed on June 13; COS
73914-Jun-1783 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 83, Order denying Brannon Kamahana Kealoha: Motion pleading for more time to submit my FOF; Motion moving to joinder all petitioners FOFs recommending denial of permit for the TMT; Motion to joinder all petitioners recommending denial of permit in regards to every single one of said petitioner's requests, motions, memos, and amendments since 12/8/17 including, but not limited to, all items ruled upon and the many not ruled upon by the honoarable (sic) Hearing Officer (Doc 663); COS
73813-Jun-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's responses to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint (proposed) Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order; COS
73713-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to J. Leinaala Sleightholm's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 670]; Appendices A-B; COS
73613-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Mehana Kihoi's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 673]; Appendices A-B; COS
73513-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's proposed Findings of Fact, and Conclusions of Law, filed May 30, 2017; Appendices A-B; COS
73413-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Flores-Case Ohana's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 664]; Appendices A-B; COS
73313-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Clarence Kukauakahi Ching's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 667]; Appendices A-B; COS
73213-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Cindy Freitas' proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision Order filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 672]; COS
73113-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint response to Harry Fergerstrom's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Recommendation, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 662]; COS
73013-Jun-17PueoPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s substantive joinder to the University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLS's joint [proposed] Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order; COS
72913-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to Joseph Kualii Lindsay Camara’s Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 661]; Appendices A-B; COS
72813-Jun-17KaheaKahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance's response to UHH/TIO proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
72713-Jun-17 UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to Temple of Lono’s proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law filed May 23, 2017 [Doc. 651], Supplement A to proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law filed May 29, 2017 [Doc. 655]; and Supplement B to proposed Decision and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law dated June 10, 2017; Appendices A-B; COS
72613-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to William Freitas' proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 669]; Appendices A-B; COS
72513-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to Tiffnie Kakalia proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 668]; Appendices A-B; COS
72413-Jun-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas response in opposition to University of Hilo and TMT International Observatory LLC's joint [proposed] Finding of Facts, Conclusions of Law and Decision & Order; Appendices A-D; Memorandum in support of opposition to UUH and TIO joint FOF, COL D & O
72313-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to Deborah Ward's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 29, 2017 [Doc. 657]; Appendices A-B; COS
72213-Jun-17TIOTMT International Observatory's joinder to The University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration Minute Order No. 53; COS
72113-Jun-17UHH, TIOThe University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint response to Kealoha Pisciotta, Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, Paul K. Neves, and Kaliko Kanaele proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order, filed May 30, 2017 [Doc. 665]; COS
72013-Jun-17SleightholmJ. Leinaala Sleightholm's response to UHH and TIO's joint Finding's of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and proposed Decision and Order (addendum to collective pro-se response); COS
71913-Jun-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's response to UHH and TIO's joint proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision Order [Doc. No. 671]; COS
71813-Jun-17Pisciotta, Anaina Hou, Ward, Neves, Kanaele, Sleightholm, Kealoha, C Freitas, KihoiPetitioners Kealoha Pisciotta, Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, D. Ward, P. Neves, K. Kanaele, L. Sleightholm, B. Kealoha, C. Freitas, M. Kihoi response to UHH / TIO proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
71713-Jun-17LonoTemple of Lono responses to applicant and TIO proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; COS
71613-Jun-17VicenteObjection to University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC's joint (proposed) Finding of Fact, Conclusion of Law, Decision and Order; COS
71512-Jun-1782 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 82, Order denying Dight (sic) Vicente's motion for stay Finding of Fact Conclusion of Law (Doc. 658): COS
71412-Jun-17FergerstromResponses to Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Recommendation; Table of Contents; COS
71312-Jun-1781 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 81, Order denying William Freitas, motion to procedural clarification concerning transcript errors (Doc. 633); COS
71212-Jun-1780 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 80, Order denying William Freitas response, to TIO's opposition to reconsideration to Minute Order's No. 43, Doc. 604, and Minute Order No. 44 Doc 614, TIO opposition and UHH joinder to TIO. Doc 607 and No. 44 Doc 616 (Doc 628); COS
71112-Jun-1779 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 79, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 47 (Doc. 619)
71011-Jun-1778 Minute Order Minute Order No. 78, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 46 (Doc. 610)
70911-Jun-1777 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 77, Order re: no decisions for non-motion submissions (Docs. Nos. 330, 366, 403, 411, 149, 421, 422, 437, 454, 460, 496, and 550); COS
70811-Jun-1776 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 76, Order denying Temple of Lono motion for protective order (Doc. 546); COS
70711-Jun-1775 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 75, Order denying Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters (Doc. 522); COS
70611-Jun-17KanaeleKalikolehua Kanaele joinder with the Flores-Case Ohana's motion for full disclosure of evidence re spoliation of evidence
70510-Jun-17C FreitasCindy Freitas joinder to Temple of Lono Supplement B to proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; COS
70410-Jun-17LonoTemple of Lono Supplement B to proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; COS
70310-Jun-1774 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 74, Order denying motion to bring on rebuttal witness on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou (Doc. 462); COS
7029-Jun-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to The University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Flores-Case 'Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence file June 2, 2017 [Doc. No. 676]; COS
7019-Jun-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration Minute Order No. 53; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
7009-Jun-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Flores-Case 'Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence file June 2, 2017 [Doc. No. 676]; COS
6999-Jun-1773 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 73, Order granting in part applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion for leave to present rebuttal testimony (Doc. 461); COS
6987-Jun-1772 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 72, Order granting Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to permit lve testimony of rebuttal witness Brian Cruz (Doc. 459): COS
6976-Jun-1771 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 71, Order granting Joseph K. L. Camara's motion to allow witness testimony (Doc. 453): COS
6966-Jun-1770 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 70, Order granting Brannon Kealoha motion of clarification reserving rights to participate (Doc. 450); COS
6956-Jun-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's joinder of Flores-Case Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence and memorandum in support of motion; COS
6946-Jun-17LonoTemple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order 57; Memorandum in support; COS
6935-Jun-1769 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 69, Order granting J. Leinaala Sleightholm's motion to appear by phone (Doc. 449); COS
6925-Jun-1768 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 68, Order denying Flores-Case Ohana's request for witness subpoena for 'John Doe' and for a subpoena duces tecum to disclose unidentified Maunakea (sic) Observatories Support Services employee involved with the destruction of ahu (shrine) on Mauna Kea in August of 2015 (Doc. 447); COS
6915-Jun-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas, pro-se, filed William Freitas's motion to amend second witness list (Doc. 166) to include William Freitas as additional witness to contested case hearing (Doc. 300) ("Motion"); COS
6905-Jun-1767 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 67, Order denying Temple of Lono request for witness subpoena for DLNR employee to testify on whether DLNR has a form to fill out requesting permission to build an altar on Mauana Kea (Doc. 439); COS
6895-Jun-1766 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 66, Order denying the Temple of Lono request for witness subpoena for David Lassner, President of the University of Hawaii system
6885-Jun-1765 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 65, Order denying the Temple of Lono motion to dismiss TIO as intervenor or alternatively, stay this proceeding (Doc. 427) and Harry Fergerstrom's motion to remove TMT/TIO as a party, for lack of standing including any and all submissions into the evidentiary library (Doc 429); COS
6874-Jun-1764 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 64, Order denying motion to be a party to TMT case by Shelley Stephens (Mahi-Hanai) (Doc. 420); COS
6864-Jun-1763 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 63, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to restore cross-examination rights (Doc. 410); COS
6854-Jun-1762 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 62, Order denying Cindy Freitas' motion to dismiss contested case hearing re: Conservation District Use Application HA-3568 (Doc. 391) (Non-hearing motion); COS
6842-Jun-1761 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 61, Order granting J. Leinaala Sleightholm's motion to accept pre-hearing statement, witness testimony, witness and exhibit list (Doc. 381); COS
6832-Jun-1760 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 60, Order denying Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing (Doc. 380); COS
6822-Jun-1759 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 59, Order denying Kamahana Kealoha motion of reconsideration on decision to motion of quo warranto (Doc. 379); COS
6812-Jun-1758 Minute Order Minute Order No. 58, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to strike for failure to serve or extension of time and rescheduling of hearing (Doc. 364); COS
6802-Jun-17UHH The University of Hawaii at Hilo joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Dwight Vicente's motion for stay Finding of Fact Conclusion of Law dated May 28, 2017 [Doc. No. 658]; COS
6792-Jun-17UHH The University of Hawaii at Hilo joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Brannon Kamahana Kealoha: Motion for more time to submit my FOF; et al. [Doc. No. 663]; Exhibit "I"; COS
6782-Jun-17TIO TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Dwight Vicente's motion for stay Finding of Fact Conclusion of Law dated May 28, 2017 [Doc. No. 658]; COS
6772-Jun-17TIO TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Brannon Kamahana Kealoha: Motion for more time to submit my FOF; et al. [Doc. No. 663]; Exhibit "I"; COS
6762-Jun-17Flores-Case Flores-Case 'Ohana's motion for full disclosure re: spoliation of evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of E. Kalani Flores; Exhibits "A", "B", and "C"; COS
6751-Jun-17LonoTemple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 53; COS
67431-May-1757 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 57, Order denying Temple of Lono motion to schedule pending motions (Doc. 324); COS
67330-May-17Kihoi Mehana Kihoi's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order; COS
67230-May-17C Freitas Cindy Freitas proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
67130-May-17UHH, TIO The University of Hawaii at Hilo and TMT International Observatory, LLC’s joint [proposed] Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, and Decision and Order; Appendices A-D; COS
67030-May-17Sleightholm J. Leinaala Sleightholm's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66930-May-17W Freitas William Freitas' proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66830-May-17KakaliaTiffnie Kakalia proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order
66730-May-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66630-May-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; Exhibit A; COS
66530-May-17Pisciotta, Anaina Hou, Neves, KanaeleKealoha Pisciotta, Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, Paul K. Neves, and Kaliko Kanaele proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66430-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66330-May-17KealohaBrannon Kamahana Kealoha: Motion pleading for more time to submit my FOF; Motion moving to joinder all petitioners FOFs recommending denial of permit for the TMT; Motion to joinder all petitioners recommending denial of permit in tregards to every dingle one of said petitioner's requests, motions, memos, and amendments since 12/8/17 including, but not limited to, all items ruled upon and the many not ruled upon by the honoarable Hearing Officer
66230-May-17FergerstromFinding of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Recommendation; Table of Contents; COS
66130-May-17CamaraJoseph Kualii Lindsey Camara's Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
66029-May-1756 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 56, Order Denying Motions for Extension of Time for Filing of Motions, Witness and Exhibit Lists and Direct Testimonies and Pre-Hearing Statements (Doc. Nos. 304, 305, 306, 323, 326, 328, 329, 337, 338); COS
65929-May-1755 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 55, Order Denying William Freitas Motion to Amend Second Witness List Doc. 166 to Include William Freitas as Additional Witness to Contested Case Hearing (Doc. 300); COS
65829-May-17D. VicenteDwight Vicente's Motion for Stay Finding of Fact Conclusion of Law; COS
65729-May-17D. WardDeborah J. Ward proposed Findings of Fact, Conclusions of Law, Decision and Order; COS
65629-May-1754 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 54, Order Denying William Freitas’ Motion to Amend Doc 281 Minute Order 19 (Doc. 283), Temple of Lono Motion for Reasoned Explanations and Extension of Time (Doc. 286), Joseph Kuali`i Lindsey Camara’s Motion to Reconsider Minute Order 19 (Doc. 291) and Temple of Lono Motion for Reconsideration (Doc. 293); COS
65529-May-17LonoTemple of Lono Supplement A to proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; COS
65427-May-1753 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 53, Order Denying the Temple of Lono Motion for Summary Judgment (Desecration) (Doc. 264) and Motions to Strike University of Hawai`i at Hilo’s and TIO Opposition to Temple of Lono Motion for Summary Judgment (Doc. No. 474 and 490); COS
65326-May-17UHHThe University of Hawai'i at Hilo's Joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's Opposition to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al's Motion for Reconsideration of Minute Order No. 49 [Doc. No. 643]; COS
65226-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's Opposition to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al. Motion for Reconsideration of MO No. 49 [Doc. No. 643]; COS
65123-May-17LonoTemple of Lono proposed Decisions and Orders including Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law; COS
65026-May-1752 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 52, Order Denying Protector/Parties' Petition for Declaratory Judgment and Motion to Vacate Minute Order No. 43, filed May 11, 2017 [Doc. 629], and Related Document [Doc. 636]; COS
64926-May-17Amended 44 Minute OrderAmended Minute Order No. 44, Documentary Evidence; COS
64826-May-17Amended COS to 50 Minute OrderAmended Certificate of Service to Minute Order No. 50
64725-May-1751 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 51, Amending Minute Order No. 44 and Granting In Part/Denying In Part Reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44
64623-May-1750 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 50, Order denying reconsideration of Minute Order No. 43; COS
64518-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to protector/parties’ petition for declaratory judgment and motion to vacate Minute Order 43 filed May 11, 2017; COS
64422-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's position statement re: William Freitas motion to procedural clarification concerning transcript errors [Doc. No. 633]; COS
64320-May-17Anaina HouMauna Kea Anaina Hou et al. motion for reconsideration; Exhibit 1; COS
64218-May-17UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to protector/parties’ petition for declaratory judgment and motion to vacate Minute Order 43 filed May 11, 2017; COS
64118-May-17UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion for reconsideration Minute Order No. 47, Filed May 5, 2017 [Doc. No. 619]; COS
64017-May-17FergerstromMotion to join the Flores-Case Ohana's motion for clarifaction reconsideration of Minute Orders 43 and 44 and also join memeorandum of support; COS
63917-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono'd motion for reconsideration Minute Order No. 46, filed May 4, 2017 [Doc. No. 610]; COS
63817-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration Minute Order No. 46, filed May 4, 2017 [Doc. No. 610]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
63717-May-1749 Minute OrderMinute Order 49, Order denying parties' petition to the Board for online access to the transcripts, filed May 5, 2017 [Doc. 622] and related document [Doc. 627]; COS
63616-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's joinder to protector/parties' petition to Board for declaratory judgment and motion to vacate Minute Order 43 [Doc. No. 629]; COS
63516-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's joinder to parties' petition to the Board for online access to the transcripts [Doc. No. 622]; COS
63415-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's motion for clarification or, in the alternative, reconsideration re: Minute Orders No. 43 and 44, filed 4/25/17 & 4/27/17 [Doc. Nos. 558 & 577]; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of E. Kalani Flores; Exhibit "A": COS
63313-May-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas, motion to procedural clarification concerning transcript errors, memorandum in support of; COS
63212-May-17Anaina Hou et alMemorandum in opposition re: UH-CDUA-BLNR-CC-16-002-UH joinder to TMT's opp to parties' petition to Board for online access to transcripts, et al.
63112-May-1748 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 48: Order denying the Temple of Lono's emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings, filed April 27, 2017 [Doc. 573] and related documents [Docs 582, 583, 584, 585, 600, 602, 624]; COS
63011-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to parties' petition to the Board for online access to the transcripts [Doc. No. 622], filed May 10, 2017 [Doc. No. 627]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "1"; COS
62911-May-17Anaina et al.Protector / parties' petition to Board for declaratory judgement and motion to vacate Minute Order 43; Memorandum in support; COS
62810-May-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas response, to TIO's opposition to reconsideration to Minute Order No. 43 Doc. 604, Minute Order No. 44 Doc. 614, TIO opposition and UHH joinder to TIO Doc 607 and No. 44 Doc. 616; COS
62710-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to parties' petition to the Board for online access to the transcripts [Doc. No. 622]; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq.; Exhibits "1"-"2"; COS
626 8-May-17UHHProof of service re: University of Hawaii at Hilo’s substantive joinder re [Doc. 555] TMT International Observatory, LLC’s motion for clarification or, in the alternative reconsideration re: Minute Order No. 44 [Doc No. 553], filed 4/24/17 [Doc. No. 556]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1-5; COS
6258-May-17TIOProof of service re: TMT International Observatory, LLC's motion for clarification or, in the alternative, reconsideration re: Minute Ordeer No. 44 [Doc. No. 553], filed 4/24/2017 [Doc. No. 555[; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq.' Exhibits "1"-"4"; COS
6247-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's joinder to Temple of Lono emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings (Doc. No. 573): COS
6237-May-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's response to applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's doc. no.s 592 & 615; Memorandum in support of response; COS
6225-May-17Anaina et alParties' petition to the BLNR for online access to the transcripts; COS
6215-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii At Hilo’s joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's statement of position re: Kahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44, filed 4/28/17 [Doc. No. 586]; COS
6205-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's statement of position re: Kahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44, filed 4/28/17 [Doc. No. 586]; COS
6195-May-17LonoTemple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 47; Memorandum in support; COS
6184-May-17UHH The University of Hawaiʻi at Hiloʼs joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLCʼs opposition to Dwight Vincente’s motion to reconsider [Doc. No. 574]; COS
6174-May-17UHH The University of Hawaiʻi at Hiloʼs joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLCʼs opposition to Cindy Freitas’ motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 571]; COS
6164-May-17UHH The University of Hawaiʻi at Hiloʼs joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLCʼs opposition to William Freitas’ motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 575]; COS
6154-May-17UHH Applicant University of Hawaiʻi at Hiloʼs opposition to Flores-Case ʻOhanaʼs motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 44 and spoliation of evidence, filed April 27, 2017 [Doc. 577]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits “Aˮ-“Gˮ; COS
6144-May-17TIO TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to William Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 575]; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq,; Exhibit "1"-"3"; COS
6134-May-17TIO TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Cindy Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 571]; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq,; Exhibit "1"; COS
6124-May-17TIO TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Dwight Vicente's motion to reconsider [Doc. No. 574]; COS
6114-May-17C Freitas Cindy Freitas memorandum in opposition to applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 44 (Doc. 553) filed April 27, 2017; COS
6104-May-17Lono Temple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 46; Memorandum in support; COS
6094-May-1747 Minute Order Minute Order No. 47: Order related to Temple of Lono motion for summary judgement (disqualification) (Doc. 263); COS
6083-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.;s joinder and objections; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1 to 2; COS
6073-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to William Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 43 [Doc. No. 568]; COS
6063-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's statement of position and opposition to Harry Fergerstrom's motion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44); Motion to include WDT and pre-hearing statement into evidence; et al., filed 4/26/17 [Doc. No. 566]; COS
6053-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's statement of position and opposition to Harry Fergerstrom's motion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44); Motion to include WDT and pre-hearing statement into evidence; et al., filed 4/26/17 [Doc. No. 566]; Exhibit "1"; COS
6043-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to William Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 43 [Doc. No. 568]; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq.; Exhibits "1" - "11"; COS
6033-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to the Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 33; (2) J. Leinaala Sleightholm's joinder to the Temple of Lono's motion to reconsider MO 44; and (3) Harry Fergerstrom's motion to Temple of Lono's motion to reconsider Minute Order 44; COS
6023-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to The University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to the Temple of Lono emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings, filed April 27, 2017 [Doc. 573]; COS
6013-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s joinder and objections; COS
6003-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to the Temple of Lono emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings, filed April 27, 2017 [Doc. 573]; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibits A-C; COS
5993-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to The Temple of Lono's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 44; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1 to 5; COS
5982-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to the Temple of Lonos motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43 [Doc. 559]; COS
5972-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's joinder to University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to the Flores-Case Ohana’s motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 43 (Doc 558); Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1 to 6; COS
5962-May-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to (1) Cindy Freitas memorandum in support of motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43, filed 4/25/17 [Doc. No. 557] and (2) Errata re Cindy Freitas memorandum in support of motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43, filed 4/26/17 [Doc. No. 562]; COS
5952-May-1746 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 46: Order related to Temple of Lono motion to recuse Hearing Officer (Doc. Nos. 262, 434, 436, 536, 544); COS
5942-May-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to the Temple of Lonos motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43 [Doc. 559]; Exhibits 1 to 5; Declaration of counsel; COS
5932-May-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo’s joinder to TMT’s Opposition to (1) Cindy Freitas Memorandum in Support of Reconsideration of Minute Order 43, Filed 4/25/17 [Doc No. 557] and (2) Errata Re Cindy Freitas Memorandum in Support of Motion for Reconsideration of Minute Order 43, Filed 4/26/17 [Doc 562]; Certificate of Service
5922-May-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to the Flores-Case Ohana’s motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 43; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1 to 6; COS
5912-May-17LonoTemple of Lono response to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al. joinder and objections; COS
5902-May-1745 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 45: Order granting in part / denying in part petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed scheduling (Doc. 254); and related Doc. Nos. 257, 258, 259, 261, 294, 296 & 298
5891-May-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory LLC's statement of position re: Harry Fergerstrom's motion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44) recently found document not previously uploaded to document library, WDT (copy attached); Motion to upload WDT into evidentiary submittals, and then moved into evidence; good cause showing filed 4/23/17 [Doc 554]; COS
58828-Apr-17TIOTMT International Observatory LLC's statement of position re: Harry Fergerstrom's motion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44); et al., filed 4/23/2017 [Doc. No. 554]; Exhibit "1"; COS
58728-Apr-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's joinder of 1) Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 44 and memorandum in support, 2) Flores-Case Ohana's motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 44 and notice of spoliation of evidence, and memorandum in support dated April 26, 2017, and 3) Mauna Kea Manau Kea (sic) Anaina Hou et al. joinder to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 44 and objections dated April 27, 2017; COS
58628-Apr-17KaheaKahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance's motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 44; Memorandum in support of motion; Exhibits "A-E;" COS
58528-Apr-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas pro-se, joinder to Temple of Lono emergency motion to stay proceedings; Memorandum in support of; COS Doc. 573
58428-Apr-17Anaina Hou et al.Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al. joinder
58328-Apr-17SleightholmJ Leinaala Sleightholm joinder to Temple of Lono emergency to stay proceedings
58228-Apr-17WardDeborah J. Ward joinder to Temple of Lono emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings
58128-Apr-17WardDeborah J. Ward joinder to Temple of Lono motion to reconsider Minute Order 44
58027-Apr-17KihoiMehana Kihoi's joinder to the Temple of Lono motion to reconsider MO 44
57927-Apr-17UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. 553]; Memorandum in support of Motion; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
57827-Apr-17Anaina Hou et al.Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al. joinder and objections
57727-Apr-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 44 and notice of spoliation of evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; Exhibit "A"; COS
57627-Apr-17SleightholmJ. Leinaala Sleightholm's joinder to the Temple of Lono's motion to reconsider MO 44
57527-Apr-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order no. 44; Memorandum in support of motion to reconsideration of Minute Order no. 44; COS
57427-Apr-17VicenteDwight Vicente's motion to reconsider; COS
57327-Apr-17LonoTemple of Lono emergency motion to Board to stay proceedings; Memorandum in support; COS
57227-Apr-17ChingClarence Kukaukahi Cing's joinder of Temple of Lono motion fo rreconsideration of Minute Order 43 and memorandum in support; COS
57126-Apr-17C FreitasCindy Freitas motion to reconsideration to Minute Order 44; Memorandum in support; COS
57026-Apr-17FergerstromMotion to Temple of Lono's motion to reconsider Minute Order 44; Memo of support
56926-Apr-17LonoTemple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 44; Memorandum in support; COS
56826-Apr-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 43; Memorandum in support of motion to reconsideration of Minute Order No. 43; COS
56726-Apr-17KealohaKamahana Kealoha joinder to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
56626-Apr-17FergerstromMotion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44); Motion to include WDT and pre-hearing statement into evidence; Motion to include as a submission of record, the testimony of Williamson Chang; Memorandum of support; Good cause Showing
56526-Apr-17SleightholmJ. Leinaala Sleightholm joinder to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
56426-Apr-17Anaina Hou et alMauna Kea Anaina Hou et al. joinder
56326-Apr-17KihoiMehana Kihoi's joinder to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
56226-Apr-17C FretiasErrata re: Cindy Freitas memorandum of support of motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
56125-Apr-17Pisciotta, Anaina Hou, NevesPetitioners Kealoha Pisciotta, Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, and Paul K. Neves join with Temple of Lono's memorandum in support of motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
56025-Apr-17WardDeborah J Ward joinder to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43
55925-Apr-17LonoTemple of Lono motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43; COS
55825-Apr-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case 'Ohana's motion to reconsider Minute Order No. 43; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
55725-Apr-17C FreitasCindy Freitas memorandum in support of motion for reconsideration of Minute Order 43; COS
55624-Apr-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's substantive joinder re TMT International Observatory's motion for clarification or, in the alternative, reconsideration re: Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 553]; COS
55524-Apr-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's motion for clarification or, in the alternative, reconsideration re: Minute Order No. 44 [Doc. No. 553]' Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama, Esq; Exhibits "1" - "7"; COS
55423-Apr-17FergerstromMotion to reconsider (Doc 553, Minute Order 44); Recently found document not previously uploaded to doc. Library, WDT (copy attached); Motion to upload WDT into evidentiary submittals, and then moved into evidence; good cause showing
55320-Apr-1744 Minute OrderMinute Order 44, Order regarding documentary evidence
552 18-Apr-1743 Minute OrderMinute Order 43, Order setting post-hearing deadlines; COS
55118-Apr-17OCCLMemorandum on contested case transcripts; Index to transcripts for Contested Case HA-16-02; COS
5506-Apr-17FergerstromReservation of all rights for all the interveners, suspended by lack of action by Hearings Officer; Memorandum of support
5494-Apr-17UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to the Temple of Lono's motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568 [Doc. 516]; Exhibits 1-6; COS
54825-Mar-17C Freitas et alCindy Freitas, William Freitas and Clarence Kukkauakahi Ching's motion for joinder of Temple of Lono's motion for protective order; COS
54724-Mar-17FergerstromMotion to join the Temple of Lono's motion for protective order (Doc 54)
546 24-Mar-17LonoTemple of Lono motion for protective order; Memorandum in support; COS
54523-Mar-17WardDeborah J. Ward joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requestnig time to respond to exhibit objections
54423-Mar-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's (1) Joinder in applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's combined opposition to the Temple of Lono's motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (disqualification) [Doc. 435], Motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion to recuse Hearing Officer [Doc. 436], and Motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (desecration) [Doc. 474]; and (2) Memorandum in opposition to Temple of Lono's motion to strike TIO's opposition to to [sic] Temple of Lono motion for summary judgement (desecration) filed September 17, 2016 [Doc 490]; COS
54323-Mar-17WardDeborah J Ward's motion for joinder in Temple of Lono motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568
54223-Mar-17Anaina Hou, Pisciotta, NevesKealoha Pisciotta, Mauna Kea Anaina Hou and Paul K. Neves' motion for joinder in Temple of Lono motion toBoard of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568
54123-Mar-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's joinder in Mauna Kea Anaina Hou's motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and realted matters, filed March 21, 2017 and in support of joinders filed by Temple of Lono, Deborah J. Ward, Harry Fergerstrom and Kalikolehua Kanaele filed on either March 21 or 22, 2017; COS
54022-Mar-17KakaliaTiffnie Kakalia's motion for joinder of 1) Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters and 2) Temple of Lono;s joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters
53922-Mar-17KihoiMehana Kihoi's motion for joinder of 1) Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters and 2) Temple of Lono;s joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters
53822-Mar-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's motion for joinder of 1) Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters and 2) Temple of Lono;s joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters
53722-Mar-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's motion for joinder in Temple of Lono motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568
53622-Mar-17UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's combined opposition to the Temple of Lono's motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (disqualification) [Doc. 435], Motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion to recuse Hearing Officer [Doc. 436], and motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (desecration) [Doc. 474]; COS
53522-Mar-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas motion to joinder Mauna Kea Anaina Hou requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters; Memorandum in support; COS
53422-Mar-17VicenteObjection to University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to motion to admit exhibits; COS
53322-Mar-17VicenteObjection to TMT International Observatory LLC's memorandum in opposition to motions to admit exhibits; COS
53222-Mar-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou's motion requesting time to respond to exhibits objections and related matters; Flores-Case Ohana's motion in opposition to University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies (Doc 514) and to TMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies (Doc 511); Memorandum in support; COS
53122-Mar-17KanaeleKalikolehua Kanaele motion to join Temple of Lono motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568
53022-Mar-17C FreitasCindy Freitas joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections
52922-Mar-17C FreitasCindy Freitas's joinder to Temple of Lono motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568
52822-Mar-17KanaeleKalikolehua Kanaele motion to join Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibits objections and related matters
52722-Mar-17Ward
Ward joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting tmie to respond to exhibit objections
52622-Mar-17LonoTemple of Lono joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters; COS
52522-Mar-17CamaraJoseph Kualii Lindsey Camara's response to UH's and TIO's opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies (Docs 511 and 516); Memorandum in support of response; COS
52421-Mar-17FergerstromMotion to join Mauna Kea Anaina Hou's motion to request time to respond to exhibit objections and matters related, and Memorandum of support
52321-Mar-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas, pro-se joinder to Temple of Lono Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568; Memorandum in support; COS
52221-Mar-17Anaina HouMauna Kea Anaina Hou motion requesting time to respond to exhibit objections and related matters; Memorandum in support
52121-Mar-17FergerstromOpposition to TMT International Observatory opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies (Doc 511); Memorandum of support
52021-Mar-17FergerstromOpposition to University of Hawaii's opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies (Doc 514); Memorandum of support
51921-Mar-17C FreitasFirst errata re: Cindy Freitas motion in opposition to the admission of exhibits A-141, A-142, A-143, and witness testimony Pat Kahawaiolaa; COS
51820-Mar-17FergerstromMotion to join the Temple of Lono's motion to dismiss and memorandum in support (Doc 516) re: desecration HRS 711-1107; Memorandum in support
51720-Mar-17KaheaErrata to Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence filed February 21, 2017; COS
51619-Mar-17LonoTemple of Lono motion to Board of Land and Natural Resources to dismiss HA-3568; Memorandum in support; COS
51518-Mar-17FergerstromClarification of items identified as evidentiary submittals under letter "D" to be moved into evidence (Doc 494); Memo of support
51416-Mar-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimony; COS
51316-Mar-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's response to applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion to admit exhibits into evidence; Memorandum in support of response; COS
51216-Mar-17C FreitasCindy Freitas motion in oppostion to the admission of exhibits A-141, A-142, A-143, A-45, A-45a, A-41 and witness testimony Sara Collins, Ph.D, David Lassner, Jesse Alan Eiben, Ph.D, Dennis Charles Gosser and Pat Kaawaiolaa; COS
51116-Mar-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to motions to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies; COS
51016-Mar-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's motion in opposition to the admission of exhibits C-41 and C-42 in TMT International Observatory, LLC's second supplement to its motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence, filed January 23, 2014; that was filed on March 9, 2017
50909-Mar-17Anaina Hou, Pisciotta, NevesMauna Kea Anaina Hou, Kealoha Pisciotta, and Paul Neves motion to admit first supplemental exhibit list and written direct testimony into evidence; COS
50809-Mar-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's second supplement to its motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence;, filed January 23, 2017; COS
50709-Mar-17WardDeborah Ward's first supplemental motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence: Memorandum in support of motion; COS
50609-Mar-17UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s supplemental motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence and objection to admission of certain exhibits and written direct testimony; Memorandum in support; COS
50509-Mar-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's second supplemental motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
50409-Mar-17SleightholmMotion to enter pre-hearing statement, witness testimony, and exhibits into evidence
50309-Mar-17KakaliaTiffnie Kakalia's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence
50209-Mar-17KihoiMehana Kihoi's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
50108-Mar-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas second supplement motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence
50008-Mar-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's motion to admit first supplemental exhibits into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
49908-Mar-17KanaeleKalikolehua Kanaele motion for admittance of exhibits and prehearing statement as my written direct testimony into evidence ("motion"); Memorandum in support of motion
49808-Mar-17VicenteDwight Vicente's motion to admit exhibits into evidence
49708-Mar-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching's supplemenetal motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; COS
49607-Mar-17
FergerstromSecond demand for an answer to document 454 (demand); Memorandum in support; COS
49507-Mar-17
Camara
Joseph Kualii Lindsey Camara's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
49406-Mar-17FergerstromFergerstrom Motion to move all documents in evidentiary hearing submittals, identified by letter "D" into evidence; memorandum of support; COS
49306-Mar-17W. FreitasWilliam Freitas First Supplemental and Amended Motion to Admit Exhibits and Written Direct Testimony Into Evidence; Memorandum in Support of Motion; COS
49203-Mar-17C. FreitasCindy Freitas First Supplemental Motion to Admit Exhibits and Written Direct Testimony Into Evidence; Memorandum in Support of Motion; COS
49103-Mar-17LonoTemple of Lono motion to admit opening statement, pre-filed testimony, and exhibits into evidence; Memorandum; COS
49003-Mar-17LonoTemple of Lono Motion to Strike TIO's Opposition to Temple of Lono Motion for Summary Judgment (Desecration) filed September 17, 2017 [Doc-264]; Memorandum; COS
48901-Mar-17KanaeleMotion for Acceptance of Exhibits M-1-2, M-A, M-4, M-E, M-7, M-I-5; COS
48801-Mar-17ChingClarence Kukauakahi Ching’s Motion to Admit Exhibits and Written Direct Testimony Into Evidence; Memorandum In Support of Motion; COS
48728-Feb-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case 'Ohana's Motion to Admit Evidence and WDT Into Evidence; Memorandum in Support of Motion; COS
48628-Feb-17KaheaKAHEA's First Supplemental Motion to Admit Exhibits and WDT Into Evidence; Memorandum in Support of Motion; COS
48528-Feb-17PUEOPerpetual Unique Education Opportunities, Inc.'s Motion to Admit Written Direct Testimony and Exhibit; COS
48428-Feb-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's Joinder to UHH's Opposition to Temple of Lono's Motion for Summary Judgment (Desecration), filed September 17, 2016 [Doc 264], filed February 22, 2017 [Doc 4763]; COS
48328-Feb-17WardDeborah Ward’s Motion to Admit Exhibits and Written Direct Testimony Into Evidence; Memorandum in Support of Motion; COS
48226-Feb-17Anaina HouMauna Kea Anaina Hou exhibits and written direct testimony offered into evidence
48126-Feb-17C FreitasCindy Freitas motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimoy into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
48026-Feb-17W FreitasWilliam Freitas motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimonies into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
47924-Feb-17UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ Granting - in part applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion for leave to present rebuttal testimony, filed February 13, 2017 [Doc. 461]; COS
47824-Feb-17KaheaProposed order granting Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to permit live testimony of rebuttal witness Brian Cruz filed February 13, 2017
47724-Feb-17Anaina Hou et alMauna Kea Anaina Hou, Kealoha Pisciotta and Paul K. Neves; Clarence Kukaukahi Ching; and Deborah J. Ward's joinder in Flores-Case Ohana's (1) request for witness subpoena for Samuel Lemmo - Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii dated January 12, 2017 (uploaded January 25, 2017); and (2) Amended request for witness subpoena for Samuel Lemmo - Adminstrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii dated and uploaded January 27, 2017; COS
47624-Feb-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's supplement to its motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence, filed January 23, 2017; COS
47524-Feb-17TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ (Order denying motion to bring on rebuttal witness on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou filed on February 13, 2017 (Doc No. 462)); COS
47422-Feb-17LonoTemple of Lono motion to strike University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (desecration) filed September 17, 2016 [Doc-264]; Memorandum; COS
47322-Feb-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (desecration), filed September 17, 2016 [Doc. 264]; COS
47221-Feb-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to admit exhibits and writeen direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
47121-Feb-17TIOTMT Internatonal Observatory, LLC's joinder to University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to permit live testimony of rebuttal witness Brian Cruz filed February 13, 2017 [Doc 459]; COS
47020-Feb-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou's motion to bring rebuttal witness on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, dated February 13, 2017; COS
46920-Feb-17UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to KAHEA: The Environmental Alliance's motion to permit live testimony of rebuttal witness Brian Cruz filed February 13, 2017 [Doc. 459]; COS
46820-Feb-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s memorandum in opposition to “Motion to bring on rebuttal witness[es] on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou” [Doc-462]; Declaration of Summer H. Kaiawe; Exhibit "1"; COS
46717-Feb-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's joinder in motion to bring rebuttal witness on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou filed February 13, 2017; COS
46617-Feb-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's response to UH Hilo's motion for leave and partial joinder in Flores-Case Ohana's response to application University of Hilo's motion fo rleave to present rebuttal testimony filed February 13, 2017, filed (on or about) February 16, 2017; Exhibit "1"; COS
46516-Feb-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's response to applicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion for leave to present rebuttal testimony; memorandum in support of response; Exhibit "a"; COS
46417-Feb-1742 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 42: Order granting Flores-Case Ohana's request for subpoena for Samuel Lemmo - Adminstrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii (Doc. No. 452) and denying the University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion to quash Flores-Case Ohana's request for Samuel Lemmo - Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii (Doc 444); COS
46316-Feb-17LonoTemple of Lono exhibits entered into evidence
46213-Feb-17Anaina HouMotion to bring on rebuttal witness on behalf of Kealoha Pisciotta and Mauna Kea Anaina Hou
46113-Feb-17UHHApplicant University of Hawaii t Hilo's motion for leave to present rebuttal testimony; Memorandum in support; Declaration of counsel
46013-Feb-17KanaeleMotion for no can come: working February 12-24 2017
45913-Feb-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to permit live testimony of rebuttal witness Brian Cruz; Memorandum in support of motion; Exhibits "1-3"
45801-Feb-17UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. __ Denying Temple of Lono Request for Witness Subpoena for DLNR Employee to Testify on Whether DLNR has a Form to Fill Out Requesting Permission to Build an Altar on Mauna Kea [Doc. 439]
45701-Feb-17UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ Denying Temple of Lono Requesting for Witness Subpoena for David Lassner, President of the University of Hawai’i System [Doc. 438] and Granting the University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s Motion to Quash Temple of Lono Request for Witness Subpoena for David Lassner, President of the University of Hawai’i System, Filed January 8, 2017 [Doc. 445]
45601-Feb-17UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. __ Denying Flores-Case ‘Ohana Request for Subpoena for “John Doe” and for a Subpoena Duces Tecum to Disclose Unidentified Maunakea Observatories Support Services Employee Involved with the Destruction of Ahu (Shrine) on Mauna Kea in August of 2015 [Doc. 447] and Granting the University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s Motion to Quash Flores-Case ‘Ohana Request for Witness Subpoena for “John Doe” and for a Subpoena Duces Tecum to Disclose Unidentified Maunakea Observatories Support Services Employee Involved with the Destruction of Ahu (Shrine) on Mauna Kea in August of 2015, Filed January 12, 2017 [Doc. 443]
45531-Jan-17KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's joinder in Flores-Case Ohana's request for witness subpoena for Samuel Lemmo - Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii dated January 12, 2017 (uploaded January 25, 2017); Exhibit "A"; COS
45431-Jan-17FergerstromDeman for a written explaination for the denial of testimony of Profesor Williamson Chang from Richardson School of Law, University of Hawaii, Manoa
45328-Jan-17CamaraJoseph K. L. Camara's motion to present witness testimony
45227-Jan-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's amended request for witness subpoena for Samuel Lemmo, Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii; Memorandum in support of amended request; Appendix "A"; COS
45127-Jan-17TIOTMT International Observatory's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of counsel; COS
45026-Jan-17KealohaBrannon Kamahana Kealoha motion reserving right to participate
44926-Jan-17SleightholmJ Leinaala Sleightholm's motion to appear by phone
44825-Jan-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana request for witness subpoena for Samuel Lemmo, Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawaii
44725-Jan-17Flores-CaseFlores-Case Ohana's request for witness subpoena for 'John Doe' and for a subpoena duces tecum to disclose unidentified Maunakea Observatories Support Services employee involved with the destruction of ahu (shrine) on Mauna Kea in August of 2015
44620-Jan-1741 Minute OrderMinute Order 41, Order regarding date to set witnesses; COS
44519-Jan-17UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s Motion to Quash Temple of Lono’s Request for Witness Subpoena for David Lassner, President of the University of Hawai‘i System, Filed January 8, 2017; Memorandum in Support of Motion
44419-Jan-17UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s Motion to Quash Flores-Case ‘Ohana’s Request for Subpoena for Samuel Lemmo-Administrator, Office of Conservation and Coastal Lands, DLNR, State of Hawai‘i, Filed January 12, 2017; Memorandum in Support of Motion;
44319-Jan-17UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s Motion to Quash Flores-Case ‘Ohana’s Request for Subpoena for “John Doe” and for a Subpoena Duces Tecum to Disclose Unidentified Maunakea Observatories Support Services Employee Involved with the Destruction of Ahu (Shrine) in Mauna Kea in August of 2015, Filed January 12, 2017; Memorandum in Support of Motion; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibit 1
44217-Jan-17UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's motion to admit exhibits and written direct testimony into evidence; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of counsel; COS
44117-Jan-17TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to motions to dismiss [Doc-427] and Doc-429]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "A"; COS
44010-Jan-17UHHApplicant University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s objection to the Temple of Lono’s motion to dismiss TIO as an intervenor or, alternatively, stay this proceeding [Doc.427] and Fergerstrom’s motion to remove TMT/TIO as a party, for lack of standing, including any and all submissions into the evidentiary library [Doc.429]; Declaration of counsel; COS
4398-Jan-17LonoTemple of Lono request for witness subpoena for DLNR employee to testify on whether DLNR has a form to fill out requesting permission to build an altar on Mauna Kea; COS
4388-Jan-17LonoTemple of Lono request for witness subpoena for David Lassner, President of the University of Hawaii System; Declaration of counsel with Exhibits A-C; COS
4373-Jan-17KanaeleMotion for no can come working January 3rd to 16 or 17th
43631-Dec-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to strike University of Hawai'i at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono motion to recuse Hearing Officer, filed September 17, 2016 [DOC-262]; Memorandum; COS
43531-Dec-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to strike University of Hawai'i at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono motion for summary judgment, filed September 17, 2016 (Disqualification) [DOC-263]; Memorandum; COS
43430-Dec-16UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion to recuse Hearing Officer, filed September 17, 2016 [Doc. 262]; COS
433 30-Dec-16UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for summary judgement (disqualification), filed September 17, 2016 [Doc. 263]; COS
43230-Dec-16 TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion for production of TIO decommissioning funding plan [Doc 431]; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
43123-Dec-16KaheaKahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion for production of TIO decommissioning funding plan; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
43023-Dec-16UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Harry Fergerstrom's opposition to the University of Hawaii's confirmation of exhibits and direct witness testimonies to be entered into evidence and motion to recall Mr. Perry J. White; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
42916-Dec-16FergerstromMotion to remove TMT/TIO as a party, for lack of standing including any and all submissions into the evidentiary library; Memorandum of support; COS
42816-Dec-16LonoTemple of Lono exhibits 1 and 2 to motion to dismiss intervenor TIO or, alternatively to stay this proceding
42715-Dec-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to dismiss TIO as intervenor or alternatively, stay this proceeding, Exhibits 1 and 2; COS
42614-Dec-16UHHProposed Minute Order No. __ denying Shelley Stephen's motion to be a party to the TMT case [Doc. 420]; COS
42511-Dec-16TIOTIO joinder to UH-Hilo’s opposition to Shelley Stevens motion to be admitted as a party to the CCH.
42411-Dec-16AmanoAmano eighth supplemental disclosure
4239-Dec-16UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition fo Shelley Stephen's motion to be a party to the TMT case, filed December 7, 2016 [Doc 420]; COS; Amended COS
4228-Dec-16KanuhaHe koi i ka luna hookolokolo e imi i palapala olelo hookolokolo oleleo Hawaii; COS
42116-Nov-16LeeMaelani Lee notice of withdrawal from case
4207-Dec-16StephensMotion to be a Party to the TMT Case; "Declaration"
41927-Nov-16KanaeleMotion for no can come; Working November 26-Dec. 7, 2016
41821-Nov-16TIONotice of change of address; COS
41717-Nov-16UHH University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion to vacate Minute Order No. 39 or, alternatively to partially reconsider Minute Order No. 39 [Doc. 409]; COS
41617-Nov-16TIOTMT International Oservatory, LLC's joinder to University of Hawai‘i at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion to restore cross-examination rights, filed November 7, 2016 [Doc. 410]; COS
41516-Nov-16UHH University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion to restore cross-examination rights, filed November 7, 2016 [Doc. 410]; COS
41416-Nov-16Stephens Written testimony concerning TMT/lease and condition violations; Evidence Holokai-Mahi report, issues of antiquities; Revoking of the TMT permit; Exhibits 1-12; Declaration
41315-Nov-16FergerstromStatement of Harry Fergerstrom
41213-Nov-16FergerstromNotice of dates in January 2017; Good cause showing
41114-Nov-16KanaeleMotion for no can come; Working until the 18th or 20th of November
4107-Nov-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to restore cross-examination rights
4096-Nov-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to vacate Minute Order No. 39 or, alternatively to partially reconsider Minute Order No. 39
408 a 408 b 408 c31-Oct-16OCCLSAMPLES: Findings of Fact,Conclusions of Law, Decisions and Orders (FOF, COL, D&O)
40728-Oct-1640 Minute OrderMinute Order 40, Order denying J Leinaala Sleightholm's motion to clarify minute order No. 36 (Doc. 376), Order voiding permit (Doc 382)
40628-Oct-1639 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 39, Order denying renewed motions to disqualify Hearing Officer (Doc 340)
40527-Oct-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's supplemental hearing memorandum re: Standard admissibility of evidenc
40424-Oct-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's amended joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's hearing memorandum re: standard for admissibility of evidence, filed October 19, 2016 [Doc 394]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
40324-Oct-16KanuhaHe noi e hoololi i kau ikepili hookaa ike
40224-Oct-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC's hearing memorandum re: standard for admissibility of evidence, filed October 19, 2016 [Doc 394]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit 1; COS
40119-Oct-16VicenteObjection to not receiving witness testimony and exhibits by mail
40020-Oct-16KanaeleKanaele join in objections of Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, Hank Fergerstrom, Dwight Vicente
399removed
39819-Oct-16Fergerstrom
Need for published change in hearing dates; Memorandum in support; COS
39719-Oct-16
KanaelePetitioner Kalikolehua Kanaele joining with petitioner's statement of position in response to the University's statement re scheduling Document 370
39619-Oct-16PUEO
Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s memorandum in opposition to Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing; Memorandum in opposition of motion; COS
39519-Oct-16TIO
TMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's joinder in Temple of Lono's motion to strike for failure to serve or extension of time and rescheduling of hearing filed October 12, 2016; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama; Exhibits 1-6' COS
39419-Oct-16TIO
TMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum re: standard for admissibility of evidence; COS
393
19-Oct-16
TIO
TMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to Kamahana motion for reconsideration on decision to motion of quo warranto filed October 15, 2016; Exhibit "1"; COS
39219-Oct-16CamaraJoseph K. L. Camara's request for November 23 court date; Oral testimony for Luana B. Neff
39118-Oct-16C FreitasMotion to dismiss Contested Case Hearing re: Conservation District Use Application HA-3568; Memorandum in support; COS
390
18-Oct-16KanaelePetitioner Kalikolehua Kanaele joining Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Peretuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing
38919-Oct-16038 Minute OrderMinute Order 38, Order denying motion to disqualify BLNR's and Hearing Officer's counsel (Doc 95)
38819-Oct-16037 Minute OrderMinute Order 37, Order denying motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568, dated September 2, 2010, and/or motion for summary judgement (Doc. 94)
38717-Oct-16KaheaJoinder in Temple of Lono's Motion to Strike for Failure to Serve or Extension of Time and Rescheduling of Hearing filed October 12, 2016; Declaration of Dexter Kaiama; Exhibits "A-B"; COS
38617-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono Response to Applicant University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s Statement of Position Regarding Petitioners’ Renewed Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer [Doc. 340] and Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel [Doc. 341]; COS
38517-Oct-16FloresNotice of Withdrawal of Flores-Case 'Ohana's Motion for 30 Day Extension of Start of Contested Case Hearing; COS
38417-Oct-16Anaina HouPetitioners' Statement of Position in Response to the University's Statement Re Scheduling Document 370; COS
38317-Oct-16Anaina HouPetitioners' Statement of Position in Response to the University's Statement Re Petitioners Renewed Motion to Disqualify Hearing Officer Document 369; COS
38216-Oct-16SleightholmJ. Leinala Sleightholm's Motion to Clarify Minute Order 36 (Doc. 376), Order Voiding Permit (Permit no. 3568), and Clarify Potential Impact of TMT on Traditional and Customary Practices in Light of the OMKM Proposed New Regulations and Suspend Proceedings; COS
38116-Oct-16SleightholmJ. Leinala Sleightholm's Motion to Accept Pre-Hearing Statement, Witness Testimony, Witness and Exhibit List; and COS
38015-Oct-16KihoiMotion for Reconsideration To Deny the Intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a Party in the Contested Case Hearing; Memorandum in Opposition of Motion; COS
37915-Oct-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha Reconsideration on Decision to Motion of Quo Warranto; COS
37815-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono Joinder with Flores-Case 'Ohana for 30 Day Extension of Start of Contested Case Hearing; COS
37714-Oct-16FloresFlores-Case 'Ohana's Motion for 30 Day Extension of Start of Contested Case Hearing; COS
37614-Oct-1636 Minute OrderMinute Order 36, Order voiding permit
37514-Oct-16HOAmano seventh supplemental discolure; COS
37414-Oct-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's memo in opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion to strike for failure to serve or extension of time and rescheduling of hearing filed October 12, 2016; Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama; Exhibits 1-7; COS
37314-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono response to applicant University of Hawai'i at Hilo's statement of position re scheduling
37214-Oct-16C FreitasIn support of UHH statement of position re scheduling; COS
37114-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono: Unresolved matters; COS
37013-Oct-16UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position re scheduling; COS
36913-Oct-16UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position regarding petitioners' renewed motion to disqualify Hearing Officer [Doc. 340] and notice of withdrawal of counsel [Doc. 341]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 1-7; COS
36813-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono second supplement to motion to strike; COS
36713-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono supplement to motion to strike; Declaration of representative; COS
36613-Oct-16C FreitasRequest for electrical hook up, technical support to hook up internet, for each parties in this pre-hearing conference and evidentiary hearing
36513-Oct-1635 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 35, Order re: dismissal of Shelley Stephen's request to be part of Contested Case Hearing (Doc. 213)
36412-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to strike for failure to serve or extension of time and rescheduling of hearing; COS
36311-Oct-1634 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 34, Order denying Kamahana Kealoha's motion demanding inventory of the so-called ceded lands containing the specific land and parcel the TIO plans to be sub-leased by UH who leases said lands from the BLNR, a survey of these lands also (Doc. 191)
36211-Oct-16KaheaNotice of appearance of co-counsel; COS
36111-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono third supplement to petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s renewed motion to disqualify Hearing Officer; COS
36011-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono second supplement to petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s renewed motion to disqualify Hearing Officer; COS
35911-Oct-16W FreitasSubstantive joinder to petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s renewal motion to disqualify hearing officer, Doc. 340; COS
35811-Oct-16KihoiMehana Kihoi's joinder to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al's renewed motion to disqualify hearing officer; COS
35710-Oct-16BLNRChristopher J. Yuen 1st supplemental disclosure, CDUA No. HA-3568 (Thirty Meter Telescope); COS
35610-Oct-1633 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 33, Order denying Temple of Lono's motion to dismiss out of time (Doc. 179); COS
35510-Oct-1632 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 32, Order denying motion to strike motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Stanley Roehrig, filed on August 8, 2016 (Doc. 187); COS
35410-Oct-1631 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 31, Order denying motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Stanley Reohrig (Doc 182); COS
35310-Oct-1630 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 30, Order denying Kamahana Kealoha: Motion invoking Quo Warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgement on a constitutional issue / violation resubmitted 8/8/2016 (Doc 180); COS
35210-Oct-1629 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 29, Order denying Temple of Lono's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction based on unresolved land claims (Doc 126); COS
35110-Oct-1628 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 28, Order denying Mehana Kihoi's motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing (Doc. 98); COS
35010-Oct-1627 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 27, Order denying Petitioners' request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date (Doc 81) and Petitioners' supplemental request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date (Doc 82); COS
34910-Oct-1626 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 26, Order denying Maelani Lee's motion to intervene (Doc 84); COS
34810-Oct-1625 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 25, Order denying Stephanie-Malia:Tabbada's motion to vacate entire process for violation of BLNR and University of Hawaii fiduciary trust, rights, responsibilities, breach of contract, etc. mandated the by the law of the land (Doc 97); COS
34710-Oct-1624 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 24, Order denying Kalikolehua Kanaele's motion to exclude/remove PUEO, TMT, UH Manoa/Hilo, and all petitioners seeking for permit for TMT by circumvention of religious protections of the Hawaii Constitution Article XI and HRS 7-11-1107 comitting desecration; COS
34610-Oct-1623 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 23, Order denying Temple of Lono's motion for partial summary judgement (Doc 78); COS
34510-Oct-1622 Minute Order Minute Order No. 22, Order denying Harry Fergerstrom's (1) Motion to reconsider all motions, application, and/or request for admission or intervention as a party or other parties in this matter; and (2) Motion to strike all motions, applications, decision, etc,: Essentially making moot the entire hearing (Doc. 96); COS
34410-Oct-1621 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 21, Order regarding fourth pre-hearing conference; COS
34310-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono substantive joinder and supplement to petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s renewed motion to disqualify hearing officer; COS
34210-Oct-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou and Kealoha Pisciotta, Clarence Kukauakahi Ching; Flores Case Ohana, Deborah J. Ward, Paul K. Neves, and Kahea: The Environmental Alliance list of e-mail addresses for service of process; COS
34110-Oct-16AnainaNotice of withdrawal of counsel; COS
34010-Oct-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s renewed motion to disqualify hearing officer; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "A"; COS
33908-Oct-16CamaraJoseph Kualii Lindsey Camara's response to amended Notice of Contested Case Hearing; COS
33808-Oct-16KanaelePetitioner Ali`i Sir Kalikolehua Kanaele KCK, motion for more time of 1 month, for due process in this instant case. and final order for motion to exclude pro desecration PUEO/TMT/UH from promoting desecration of a conservation district
33707-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono supplement to motion for extension of time; COS
33607-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono response to University of Hawai`i at Hilo [proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono motion to dismiss out of time [Doc-179] [318]; Exhibits 1 and 2; COS
33507-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono response to [proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono's motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction based on unresolved land claim [Doc-126] [310], Exhibit 1; COS
33407-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono response to [proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono motion for partial summary judgement [Doc-78] [Doc-315]; Exhibit 1; COS
33307-Oct-16C FreitasObjection to all Minute Order No. ___ that was filed in the document library on October 5, 2016 Doc 322, 321, 320, 319, 318, 317, 316, 315, 314, 313, 312, 311, 310, 309, and 308; COS (duplicate)
33207-Oct-16C FreitasObjection to all Minute Order No. ___ that was filed in the document library on October 5, 2016 Doc 322, 321, 320, 319, 318, 317, 316, 315, 314, 313, 312, 311, 310, 309, and 308; COS
33107-Oct-16C FreitasObjection to Minute Order No. ___ that Hearing Officer order on October 3, 2016; COS
33007-Oct-16SleightholmJ. Lenia`ala Sleightholm's motion to update contact information; COS
32907-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for extension of time for filing of final witness list and prefiled testimony, exhibit list and exhibits, prehearing statement, and motions; COS
32806-Oct-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha - Essential extension of time for filling of motions and witness and exhibit lists and direct testimonies and pre-hearing statement and request/demand for reconciliation on following items; COS
32706-Oct-16KihoiProposed Minute Order No. ___ objection to proposed Minute Order No.___ denying Mehana Kihoi's motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the Contested Case Hearing (Doc 98): COS
32606-Oct-16SleightholmMotion for extension of filing motions, witness and exhibit lists direct testimonies and pre-hearing statements; Memorandum in support of motion for extension of filing motions, witness and exhibit lists direct testimonies and pre-hearing statements
32506-Oct-16HOAmended Notice of Contested Case Hearing; COS
32406-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to schedule pending motions; COS
32305-Oct-16KihoiMotion for extension of filing motions, witness and exhibit lists direct testimonies and pre-hearing statements; COS
32205-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ Denying Maelani Lee’s motion to intervene [Doc. 84]; COS
32105-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Kalikolehua Kanaele’s motion to exclude/remove PUEO, TMT, UH Manoa/Hilo, and all petitioner’s seeking for permit for TMT by circumvention of religious protections of the Hawaii Constitution Article XII and HRS 7-11-1107 committing desecration [Doc. 173]; COS
32005-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Shelley Stephens’ request to be part of Contested Case Hearing [Doc. 213]; COS
31905-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying petitioners’ request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date [Doc. 81] and petitioners’ supplemental request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date [Doc. 83]; COS
31805-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono motion to dismiss out of time [Doc. 179]; COS
31705-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Brannon Kamahana Kealoha’s motion demanding inventory of the so-called ceded lands containing the specific land and parcel the TIO plans to be sub-leased by UH who leases said lands from the BLNR, a survey of these lands also, filed August 10, 2016 [Doc. 191]; COS
31605-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Stephanie-Malia:Tabbada’s motion to vacate entire process for violation of BLNR and University of Hawaii fiduciary trust, rights, responsibilities, breach of contract, etc. mandated by the law of the land, filed July 18, 2016 [Doc. 97]; COS
31505-Oct-16UHH[Proposed] Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono motion for partial summary judgment [Doc. 78]; COS
31405-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying motion to strike motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case, and Stanley Roehrig, filed on August 8, 2016 [Doc 187]; COS
31305-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing [Doc 209]; Memorandum in opposition; COS
31205-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Standley Roehrig; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
31105-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Kamahana Kealoha: Motion invoking Quo Warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgement on a constitutional issue / violation resubmitted 8/8/2016 [Doc 180]; COS
31005-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Temple of Lono motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction based on unresolved land claims (Doc 126); COS
30905-Oct-16TIOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Harry Fergerstrom's (1) Motion to reconsider all motions, application, and/or request for admission as a party or other parties in this matter; and (2) Motion ot strike all motions, applications, decisions, etc.; essentially making moot the entire hearing [Doc 96]; COS
30805-Oct-16PUEOProposed Minute Order No. ___ denying Mehana Kihoi's motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the Contested Case Hearing (Doc 98): COS
30705-Oct-16HORe: Contested case Hearing in re Thirty Meter Telescope CDUP application: Amano sixth supplemental disclosure; COS
3064-Oct-16KihoiMotion for extension of time for filing of motions, witness and exhibit lists and direct testimonies and pre-hearing statement; Memorandum in support; COS
3054-Oct-16C FreitasMotion for extension of time for filing of motions, witness and exhibit lists and direct testimonies and pre-hearing statement; Memorandum in support; COS
3044-Oct-16W FreitasMotion for extension of time for filing of motions, witness and exhibit lists and direct testimonies and pre-hearing statement; Memorandum in support; COS
3033-Oct-16
UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s opposition to Joseph K. L. Camara’s motion to reconsider Minute Order 19, filed September 28, 2016 [Doc. 192]; Exhibit “1”; Declaration of Counsel; COS
3023-Oct-16
UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s joinder  to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration filed September 28, 2016 [Doc-293]; COS
3013-Oct-16
TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's memorandum in opposition to Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration filed September 28, 2016; COS
30003-Oct-16W FreitasWilliam Freitas's motion to amend second witness list Doc. 166 to include William Freitas as additional witness to contested case hearing
29903-Oct-16KanaeleMotion to join Richard Wurdeman request for further status conference and/or consideration rescheduling
29803-Oct-16KanaeleMotion to join attorney for the petitioners Richard Wurdeman's response to Unique Educational Opportunities Inc. proposed minute order granting motion to set issues filed September 9 2016
29703-Oct-16C FreitasRespond to proposed Doc 256 all issue should also be considered
29603-Oct-16LonoTemple of Lono support for Petitioners Mauna Keas Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed scheduling [Doc-254]
29530-Sep-16BLNRNotice of Disclosure of Board Member Stanley H. Roehrig re CDUA HA-2568 (Thirty Meter Telescope); COS
29430-Sep-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s objection to Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.’s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed scheduling, filed September 8,2016 [Doc. 254]; Exhibits 1-3; Declaration of Counsel; COS
29329-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for reconsideration; Memorandum in support; COS
29228-Sep-16W FreitasWilliam Freitas motion to joinder in support of Joseph Kuali`i Lindsey Camara's motion to reconsider Minute Order 19. Dpc 281; COS
291 28-Sep-16CamaraJoseph Kuali`i Lindsey Camara's motion to reconsider Minute Order 19; COS
29027-Sep-16C FreitasC Fretias objection to September 26, 2016 site visit on Mauna Kea; COS
28926-Sep-1620 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 20: Order setting fifth pre-hearing conference; COS
28826-Sep-16AnainaPetitioner Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s objections to sire visit and Minute Order No. 18; COS
287 26-Sep-16CamaraJoseph K. L. Camara's response to Minute Order 18 (site visit); COS
286 26-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for reasoned explanations and extension of time; Memorandum in support; COS
28526-Sep-16C FreitasMotion to object to phone call by Michael Cain on 9/23/16 that was instructed by Hearing Officer Judge Riki Amano (ret.); COS
28426-Sep-16C FreitasMotion to amend doc 281 Minute Order no. 19; COS
28326-Sep-16W FreitasMotion to amend Doc 281 Minute Order No. 19; COS
28223-Sep-16AnainaCorrespondence regarding notice of contested case hearing; COS
28123-Sep-1619 Minute OrderMinute Order 19: Order granting Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.’s motion to set the issues Doc. 99; Order setting issues; COS
28022-Sep-16SleightholmJ Leina`ala Sleightholm's motion of opposition and request to amend Minute Order No. 18 Doc 274; COS
279
22-Sep-16KihoiKihoi memorandum re: site vist; COS
27821-Sep-16C FreitasMotion to amend Doc 274 site visit to include areas proposed in Doc 220; COS
27721-Sep-16W FreitasMotion to amend Doc 274 site visit to include areas proposed in Doc 214; COS
27620-Sep-16HONotice of Contested Case Hearing; Star-Advertiser ad order confirmation; COS
27519-Sep-16TabbadaResponse to Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s proposed minute order motion to set the issues; COS
27419-Sep-1618 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 18: Order regarding site visit to Mauna Kea - September 26, 2016; COS
27319-Sep-16KakaliaAddition to PUEO's motion to set issues [Doc-256]; COS
27219-Sep-16VicenteObjection to PUEO's motion to set the issues [Doc-99]; Exhibit A; COS
27119-Sep-16W FreitasRespond to issue that all should be considered; COS
27019-Sep-16AnainaMauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al. Petitioners' response to P.U.E.O., Inc.'s proposed minute order granting P.U.E.O., Inc.'s motion to set issues; COS
26919-Sep-16CamaraJoseph Kuali`i Lindsey Camara's response to Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.;s proposed minute order granting Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set the issues; Exhibit "A"; COS
26819-Sep-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's response to Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.;s proposed Minute Order granting Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set the issues (Doc-99) [Doc 256]; Exhibits "1" and "2"; COS
26719-Sep-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s response in support of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.’s proposed minute order granting PUEO’s motion to set issues (Doc.-99) [Doc. 256]; COS
26618-Sep-16FergerstromFergerstrom opposition to Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.;s proposed minute order granting Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set the issues; Memorandum of support; COS
26517-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono proposed issues; Exhibit "A"; COS
26417-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for summary judgement (desecration); Memorandum in support; COS
26317-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for summary judgement (disqualification); Memorandum in support; COS
26217-Sep-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to recuse Hearing Officer; Memorandum in support; COS
26114-Sep-16KihoiMemorandum in support of Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed schdeduling (sic) Doc 254; COS
26014-Sep-16KihoiKihoi site visit proposal
25912-Sep-16C FreitasMemorandum in support of Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed schdeduling (sic); COS
25812-Sep-16W FreitasMemorandum in support of Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed schdeduling (sic); COS
25711-Sep-16FergerstromMemorandum in support of Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed schdeduling; COS
2569-Sep-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s proposed minute order granting Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set issues [Doc-99]; Exhibit "A"; COS
2559-Sep-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s Site Visit Designation; COS
2548-Sep-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s request for further status conference and/or consideration of proposed scheduling; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibits "A" - "B"; COS
2537-Sep-16KanaeleWitness List; COS
2522-Sep-16FergerstromNotice of family burial claim under the proposed TMT Site; Copy of claim with SHPD; COS
2511-Sep-16DeLeonMotion to Withdraw Richard Maele DeLeon as party to the contested case and witness under my name
2501-Sep-16xMotion to withdraw Ku`uipo Freitas as witness; Memorandum in support; COS
24930-Aug-16DeLeonMotion to withdraw from contested case
24829-Aug-16Fergerstrom Notice of the appearance of administrative bias
24729-Aug-16FergerstromMemorandum of clarity that this case is in fact a land case and not a political question; COS
24626-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's request for Board to act upon denial of intervention pursuant to HAR Sect. 13-1-31(G); Declaration of Ross T. Shinyama; Exhibit "1"' COS
24526-Aug-1617 Minute OrderMinute Order 17: Order denying motion objecting to the Hearing Officer and the Hearing Officer Selection Process; COS
24425-Aug-16FergerstromMemorandum in support of Temple of Lono motion to file motion out of time; COS
24322-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s Memorandum in Opposition to Brannon Kamahana Kealoha’s Kamahana Kealoha: Invoking American Law; Motion Demanding Inventory of the So-Called Ceded Lands Containing the Specific Land and Parcel the TIO Plans to be Sub-Leased by UH Who Leases Said Lands from the BLNR, A Survey of These Lands Also, Filed August 10, 2016 [Doc. 191]; Certificate of Service filed August 22, 2016.
24222-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s supplemental comments on Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.’s motion to set the issues [Doc 99]; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibit “1”; COS
24122-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s objections to the untimely motions and joinders filed by anti-TMT parties including, But Not Limited to, Doc. Nos. 178, 179, 187, 190, 191, 192, 193, and 195, filed August 11, 2016 [Doc. 203]; COS
24022-Aug-16FergerstromLate filing of witness list; Good casue showing; Witness information; COS
23922-Aug-16Tabbada(A) Response to University of Hawaii oppositions doc 139, 194, 196, 197, 198, 199, 200, 201, 202; (B) Support Kamahana Kealoha quo warranto doc 180; (C) Support Dwight Vincente filings; (D) Response to motion for protective order doc 182; (E) In support of Richard Wurdeman's motion to strike CDUA application HA-3568 discussed 8/12/2016; COS
23822-Aug-1616 Minute OrderMinute Order 16: Order regarding third prehearing conference; COS
23722-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's substantive joinder to applicant The University of Hawaii at Hilo's memorandum in opposition to Kamahana Kealoha's Kamahana Kealoha: Invoking American law; Motion demanding inventory of the so-called ceded lands containing the specific land and parcel the TIO plans to be sub-leased by UH who leases said lands from the BLNR, a survey of these lands also, filed August 10, 2106 [Doc. 191]; COS
23622-Aug-16SleightholmJ. Leina`ala Sleightholm's joinder to Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing dated 08/12/2016
23522-Aug-16SleightholmJ. Leina`ala Sleightholm's memorandum in support of Temple of Lono motion to file out of time
23422-Aug-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s memorandum in opposition to Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing; COS
23322-Aug-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s memorandum in opposition to motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Stanley Reohrig, filed on August 8, 2016; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "A" - "H"; COS
23222-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing; Declaration of J. Douglas Ing; Exhibit "1"; COS
23122-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Kamahana Kealoha: Motion demanding redress to the fact that we are being rushed, coerced and intimidated through this process by the Hearing’s Officer and through silence and verbal prodding as well as through the silence and lack of action of the Attorney General’s Office [Doc-190]; COS
23022-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's objections to the site visit proposal by Cindy Freitas; COS
22922-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's objections to Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s site visit recommendations; COS
22822-Aug-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha motion to join Mehana Kihoi's motion for reconsideration of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case
22722-Aug-16C FreitasMotion to file out of time; COS
22622-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai‘i at Hilo’s joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Mehana Kihoi’s motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party in the contested case hearing [Doc-209]; COS
22522-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaiʻi at Hiloʼs joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC’S opposition to Kamahana Kealoha: Motion demanding redress to the fact that we are being rushed, coerced, and intimidated through this process by the Hearing's Officer and through silence and verbal prodding as well as through silence and lack of action of the Attorney General's Office [Doc-190]; COS
22422-Aug-16BLNRGovernor David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Stanley Roehrig's memorandum in opposition to petitioners' motion to strike motion for protective order for The Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case, and Stanley Reohrig filed on August 8, 2016; COD
22322-Aug-16BLNRSecond amended Certificate of Service [Motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case, and Stanley Reohrig]
22220-Aug-16VicenteObjection of ("PUEO") motion to set the issue
22119-Aug-16KilaGlen Kila memorandum in support of Temple of Lono motion to file motion out of time
22017-Aug-16C FreitasSite visit proposal; COS
21917-Aug-16FergerstromFergerstrom correspondence regarding Mauna Kea site visit
21817-Aug-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s site visit recommendations; COS
21717-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's proposal for site visit; COS
21617-Aug-16SleightholmSleightholm list of site visit attendees
21517-Aug-16UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo's site visit designations; COS
21417-Aug-16W FreitasSite visit proposal
21317-Aug-16xShelley C. Stephens (Mahi Hanai) request to be part of Contested Case Hearing
21216-Aug-16C FreitasCindy Freitas withdrawal of motion for reconsideration [Doc 205] without prejudice
21115-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono withdrawal of motion for reconsideration [Doc-178] without prejudice; COS
2108-Aug-16SleightholmJ. Leniaʻala Sleighholm's joinder to Hank Fergerstrom's motion to opposed PUEO's motion to set issues.
20912-Aug-16KihoiKihoi motion for reconsideration to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing; Memorandum in opposition; COS
20811-Aug-16VicenteVicente objection of the protective order file dated August 8, 2016
20711-Aug-16W FreitasWilliam Freitas's joinder to Cindy Freitas motion to reconsideration; COS
20611-Aug-16FergerstromFergerstrom opposition to TMT International Observatory's opposition to Kamahana Kealoha motion invoking quo warranto; Memorandum in support; COS.
20511-Aug-16C FreitasCindy Frietas motion to reconsideration; Memorandum in support; COS
20411-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's objections to J. Leina`ala Sleightholm's joinder to Mehana Kihoi's motion to exclude PUEO as a party [doc-192]; COS
20311-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's objections to the untimely motions and joinders filed by anti-TMT parties including, but not limited to, doc. nos. 178, 179, 187, 190, 191, 192, 193, and 195; COS
20211-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaiʻi at Hilo’s Joinder to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Kamahana Kealoha: Motion invoking quo warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgment on a constitutional issue/violation resubmitted 8/8/2016, filed August 9, 2016 [Doc. 184]; COS
20111-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaiʻi at Hilo’s joinder to David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case And Stanley Roehrig’s motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Stanley Roehrig, filed August 8, 2016 [Doc. 182]; COS
20011-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion for reconsideration, filed August 7, 2016 [Doc. 178] COS
19911-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaiʻi at Hilo’s Joinder as to Part (3) of TMT International Observatory LLC’s objections to (1) Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration; (2) Temple of Lono motion to file motion out of time; and (3) Joseph K.L. Camara’s joinder to Richard Naiwieha Wurderman’s motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568 dated September 2, 2010 and/or motion for summary judgment, filed August 9, 2016 [Doc. 183]; COS
19811-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s objection to J. Leina’ala Sleightholm’s joinder to Temple of Lono motion to file out of time filed August 10, 2016 [Doc. 193]; COS
19711-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s Objection to J. Leina’ala Sleightholm’s joinder to Mehana Kihoi’s motion to exclude Pueo as a party, filed August 10, 2016 [Doc. 192]; COS
19611-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawai’i at Hilo’s objection to (1) Harry Fergerstrom’s opposition to Pueo’s motion to set the issues, filed August 9, 2016 [Doc. 186]; (2) J. Leina’ala Sleightholm’s joinder to Hank Fergustrom’s [sic] motion to oppose Pueo’s motion to set issues, filed August 10, 2016 [Doc. __]; and (3) Mehana Kihoi’s joinder to Hank Fergerstrom’s motion to Oppose P.U.E.O. LLC’s motion to set the Issues, filed August 10, 2016; COS
19510-Aug-16KihoiMehana Kihoi's joinder to Hank Fergerstrom's motion to oppose P.U.E.O. LLC's motion to set the issues; COS
19410-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion to file out of time [Doc. 179]; COS
19310-Aug-16Sleightholm Leina`ala Sleightholm joinder to Temple of Lono motion to file motion out of time
19210-Aug-16SleightholmJ. Leina`ala Sleightolm's joinder to Mehana Kihoi's motion to exclude PUEO as a party
19110-Aug-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha: Invoking American law; motion demanding inventory of the so-called ceded lands containing the specific land and parcel the TIO plans to be sub-leased by UH who leases said lands from the BLNR, a survery of these lands also
19010-Aug-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha: Demanding redress to the fact that we are being rushed, coerced, and intimidated through this process by the Hearing's Officer and through silence and verbal prodding as well as through silence and lack of action of the Attorney General's Office.
18910-Aug-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha: Response to TMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to motion invoking quo warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgement on a constitutional issue/violation resubmitted 8/8/2016
18810-Aug-16AnainaWurdeman correspondence addressed to Hearing Officer Judge (Ret.) Riki May Amano and BLNR Chair Suzanne Case re: Hearing on Petitioners' motion to disqualify BLNR's and Hearing Officer's counsel, Filed on July 18, 2016, filed on August 10, 2016.
18710-Aug-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou, et al.'s motion to strike motion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case, and Stanley Roehrig, filed on August 8, 2016, filed on August 10, 2016;
1869-Aug-16FergerstromFergerstrom opposition to PUEO's motion to set the issues; Memorandum of support
1859-Aug-1615 Minute OrderMinute Order 15: Order regarding change of location for August 12, 2016 continued hearing and 3rd pre-hearing conference; COS
1849-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's opposition to Kamahana Kealoha: Motion invoking Quo Warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgement on a constitutional issue / violation resubmitted 8/8/2016; COS
1839-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's objections to (1) Temple of Lono motion for reconsideration; (2) Temple of Lono motion to file motion out of time; and (3) Jospeh K.L. Camara's joinder to Richard Naiwieha Wurderman's motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568 dated September 2, 2101, and/or motion for summary judgement; COS
1828-Aug-16BLNRMotion for protective order for the Honorable David Y. Ige, Suzanne Case and Standley Roehrig; Memorandum in support of motion; COS
1818-Aug-16CamaraJoseph K. L. Camara's joinder to Richard Naiwieha Wurderman's motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568 dated September 2, 2101, and/or motion for summary judgement; COS
1808-Aug-16KealohaKamahana Kealoha: Motion invoking Quo Warranto, respectfully, a demand of jurisdiction; Declaratory judgement on a constitutional issue / violation resubmitted 8/8/2016; COS
1798-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to file motion out of time; Exhibits 1 and 2, COS
1787-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for reconsideration; Memorandum in support; COS
1775-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono reply to TMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Temple of Lono motion to vacate ruling and supplement response Time [Doc. 127]; COS
1763-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono reply to the University of Hawaii at Hilo's opposition to Temple of Lono's motion for partial summary judgement [Doc-78]; COS
1753-Aug-16LonoTemple of Lono response to TMT International Observatory, LLC's response to the purported Kingdom of Hawaii's notice of absence and inddispensible parties [Doc-79]; COS
1741-Aug-16TabbadaTabbada motion to support (1) of the Temple of Lono's motion to vacate the Board's Minute Order No. 14 and (2) Dwight Vicente filing of July 29, 2016; (3) Motion to support Mehana Kihoi motion to deny the PUEO opportunities as a party; COS
17329-Jul-16KanaelaKanaele motion to exclude/remove PUEO, TMT, UH Manoa/Hilo, and all Petitioners seeking for permit for TMT by circumvention of religious protections of the Hawaii Constitution Article XII and HRS 7-11-1107 committing desecration; COS
1722-Aug-16DeLeonRichard L. DeLeon first amended witness list; COS
1711-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaiʻi at Hilo’s Witness List - resubmitted pursuant to Minute Order No. 13; COS
1701-Aug-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.s joinder in The University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou and Kealoha Pisciotta, Clarence Kukauakahi Ching, Flores-Case Ohana, Deborah J. Ward, Paul K. Neves and KAHEA: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance’s motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3569, dated September 2, 2010, and/or motion for summary judgment, filed July 18, 2016; COS
1691-Aug-16VicenteDwight J. Vicente motion to support of the Temple of Lono's motion to vacate the Board's July 22, 2016, Minute Order No. 14; COS
1681-Aug-16Anaina(email) Note for the record
1671-Aug-16KilaGlen Kila witness list; COS
1661-Aug-16W FreitasWilliam Freitas first amended witness list; COS
1651-Aug-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s witness list (resubmitted); COS
1641-Aug-16AnainaMauna Kea Anaina Hou, et. al. Petitioners' position statement on Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set the issues, dated July 18, 2016; COS
1631-Aug-16AnainaMauna Kea Anaina Hou, et. al. Petitioners' initial objections to witnesses designated by other parties; COS
1621-Aug-16SleightholmJ. Leina`ala Sleightholm witness list (resubmitted); COS
1611-Aug-16KealohaBrannon Kamahana Kealoha quo warranto, demand of jurisdiction; COS
1601-Aug-16KakaliaTiffnie Kakalia witness list (resubmitted); COS
1591-Aug-16KihoiMehana Kihoi witness list (resubmitted); COS
1581-Aug-16C FreitasCindy Freitas witness list (resubmitted); COS
1571-Aug-16BLNRAttorney General Douglas S. Chin, The Department of the Attorney General,and Deputy Attorneys General in their capacity as counsel for the Board of Land and Natural Resources and Hearing Officer's, Memorandum in opposition to Petitioners Mauan Kea Anaina Hou; Keahola Pisciotta; Clarence Kukaukahi Ching; Flores Case-Ohana; Deborah J. Ward; Paul K. Neves and Kahea: The Environmental Alliance's motion to disqualify the BLNR's and Hearing Officer's counsel; Declaration of Douglas S. Chin; Declaration of William J. Wynhoff; Declaration of Julie H. China; COS
1561-Aug-16BLNRNotice of special appearance as Special Deputy Attorneys General for Attorney General Douglas S. Chin, The Department of the Attorney General,and Deputy Attorneys General in their capacity as counsel for the Board of Land and Natural Resources and Hearing Officer; COS
1551-Aug-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.s memorandum in opposition to Mehana Kihoi's motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing; COS
1541-Aug-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s joinder in The University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion for partial summary Judgment; COS
1531-Aug-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.s joinder in The University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Petitioners’ motion to disqualify BLNR’s and Hearing Officer’s counsel, filed July 18, 2016; COS
1521-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s substantive joinder in Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.’s motion to set the issues [Doc. 99]; COS
1511-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s response to the purported Kingdom of Hawaii’s notice of absence of necessary and indispensable parties [Doc. 79]; COS
1501-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Temple of Lono motion to vacate ruling and supplement response Time [Doc. 127]; COS
1491-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to the Temple of Lono motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction Based on Unresolved Land Claims [Doc. 126]; COS
1481-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou and Kealoha Pisciotta, Clarence Kukauakahi Ching, Flores-Case Ohana, Deborah J. Ward, Paul K. Neves, and Kahea: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance’s motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568, dated September  2, 2010, and/or motion for summary judgment filed July 18, 2016 [Doc. 94]; COS
1471-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to motion to disqualify BLNR’s and Hearing Officer’s counsel; COS
1461-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Maelanai Lee’s motion to intervene [Doc-84]; COS
1451-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to Mehana Kihoi’s motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing dated July 18, 2016 [Doc. 98]; COS
1441-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s opposition to the three motions filed by Harry Fergerstrom [Doc. 96];  COS
1431-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s objections to witness lists; COS
1421-Aug-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC’s joinder in (1) The University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion for partial summary judgment; and (2) The University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to living heir/proper party/Petitioner Stephanie-Malia Tabbada’s motion to vacate entire process for violation of BLNR and University of Hawai’i fiduciary trust, rights, responsibilities, breach of contract, etc. mandated by the law of the land; COS
1411-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s objections to immaterial, irrelevant and unduly repetitious witness testimony; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "1"; COS
1401-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s substantive joinder in support of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities’ motion to set the issues, filed July 18, 2016 [Doc. 99]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "1" - "2"; COS
1391-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to living heir/proper party/Petitioner Stephanie-Malia Tabbada’s motion to vacate entire process for violation of BLNR and University of Hawaii fiduciary trust, rights, responsibilities, breach of contract, etc. mndated by the law of the land [Doc. 97]; COS
1381-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Petitioners’ motion to disqualify BLNR’s and Hearing Officer’s Counsel, filed July 18, 2016 [Doc. 95]
1371-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Petitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou and Kealoha Pisciotta, Clarence Kukauakahi Ching, Flores-Case Ohana, Deborah J. Ward, Paul K. Neves and KAHEA: The Hawaiian Environmental Alliance’s motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3569, dated September 2, 2010, and/or motion for summary judgment, filed July 18, 2016 [Doc. 94]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "1" to "9"; COS
1361-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s memorandum in opposition to Maelani Lee’s Motion to intervene filed July 13, 2016 [Doc. 84]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "1"; COS
1351-Aug-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo’s opposition to Temple of Lono’s motion for partial summary judgment [Doc. 78]; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "1" - "2"; COS
13429-Jul-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s witness list (resubmitted); COS
13328-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono notice of citations; COS
13227-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono response in support of intervenor Dwight J. Vicente motion to disqualify Judge Riki May Amano (ret.); State of Hawaii lack of jurisdiction to hear this contested case hearing; Exhibit 1 with Exhibits A and B; COS
131xx(duplicate)
13026-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s: (1) Renewal of objections to hearing officer selection process and hearing officer appointment, and (2) supplemental arguments on motion to disqualify BLNR's and Hearing Officer's counsel, filed on July 18, 2016; Declaration of Richard Naiweha Wurdeman; Exhibits "A" - "D"; COS
12926-Jul-16KealohaWitness list (resubmitted); COS
12825-Jul-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC witness list (reformatted): COS
12722-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to vacate ruling and supplement response time; Exhibit 1 (declaration of Lanny Alan Sinkin); COS
12622-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono motion to dismiss for lack of jurisdiction based on unresolved land claims; Memorandum in support; Exhibit 1; COS
12521-Jul-16W FreitasW Freitas reply to TMT International Observatory LLC's and UH responses to Petitioners' request for a continuance letter sign on July 15, 2016; COS
12422-Jul-1614 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 14: Order denying Dwight J. Vicente's motion to disqualify Judge Riki May Amano (ret.); State of Hawaii lack of jurisdiction tohear the contested case hearing; COS
12322-Jul-16DeLeonMotion to join
12222-Jul-16KanaeleMotion to join
12121-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono witness list (resubmitted); COS
12020-Jul-16TIOTMT International Observatory witness list
11920-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono opposition to PUEO motion to set the issues; COS
11819-Jul-16KealohaKamahana witness under protest of deadline and motion to extend (2)
11718-Jul-16KealohaKamahana witnesses under protest of deadline and motion to extend
11618-Jul-16KihoiWitness list; COS
11521-Jul-1613 Minute OrderMinute Order 13: Order on the hearing on admission or intervention as a party; Second pre-hearing conference; COS
11420-Jul-16C FreitasReply to TMT International Observatory LLC's and UH responses to Petitioners' request for a continuance letter sign on July 15, 2016; COS
11320-Jul-16KanaeleWitness list
11218-Jul-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s first amended witness list; COS
11118-Jul-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s witness list; COS
11018-Jul-16KanuhaWitness list
10918-Jul-16KakaliaWitness list
10818-Jul-16DeLeonWitness list
10718-Jul-16CamaraWitness list
10618-Jul-16UHHApplicant University of Hawaii at Hilo's Witness List; COS
10518-Jul-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's witness list; COS
10418-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s supplemental witness list; COS
10318-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s witness list; COS
10218-Jul-16W FreitasWitness list
10118-Jul-16C FreitasWitness list
10018-Jul-16LonoTemple of Lono Witness List; COS
09918-Jul-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to set the issues; COS
09818-Jul-16KihoiKihoi motion to deny the intervention of Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities as a party to the contested case hearing; Memorandum in opposition of motion; COS
09718-Jul-16TabbadaTabbada motion to vacate entire process for violation of BLNR and University of Hawaii fiduciary trust, rights, responsibilities, breach of contract, etc. mandated the by the law of the land; COS
09618-Jul-16FergerstromFergerstrom motion to reconsider all motions, application, and / or request for admission or intervention as a party or other parties in this matter; Motion to strike all motions, applications, decisions, etc.: essentially making moot the entire hearing; Motion to remove Hearing Office Riki May Amano, Attorney General Julie China, and Director of Coastal and Conservation Lands Michael Cain; COS
09518-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s motion to disqualify BLNR's and Hearing Officer's counsel; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of Richard Naiwieha Wurdeman; Exhibits "A" - "E;" COS
09418-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s motion to strike Conservation District Use Application, HA-3568, dated September 2, 2010, and/or motion for summary judgement; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of Richard Naiwieha Wurdeman; Exhibits "A" - "E;" COS
09318-Jul-16TIOTMT International Observatory's response to Petitioners' request for a continuance of the motions deadline; COS
09218-Jul-16SleightholmRequest for continuance on witness list and next hearing date
09118-Jul-16KilaRequest for continuance on witness list and next hearing date
09018-Jul-16W FreitasRequest for continuance on witness list and next hearing date
08918-Jul-16C FreitasRequest for continuance on witness list and next hearing date
08815-Jul-16KanaeleJoining of motions for continuance with Richard Naiwi Wurdeman's motion, and opposition to UH opposition to Richard Naiwi Wurdeman's motion for continuance; COS
08714-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s reply to TMT International Observatory LLC's and UH responses; COS
08614-Jul-16UHHUH-Hilo's opposition to Petitioners' request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date; COS
08514-Jul-16TIOTMT International Observatory LLC's response to Petitioners' request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date; COS
08413-Jul-16LeeMotion to intervene; COS
08312-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s supplement to request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date; COS
08212-Jul-1612 Minute OrderMinute Order 12: Order denying Temple of Lono's motion for refund of filing fee, filed June 23, 2016; COS
08111-Jul-16AnainaPetitioners Mauna Kea Anaina Hou et al.'s request for continuance on submissions and next hearing date; COS
08024-Jun-16VicenteDwight J. Vicente motion to disqualify Judge Riki May Amano (ret.); State of Hawaii lack of jurisdiction to hear this contested case; COS
07922-Jun-16LonoKingdom of Hawaii notice of absence of necessary and indispensible parties; Exhibits 1-3; COS
07821-Jun-16LonoTemple of Lono motion for partial summary judgment; Temple of Lono memorandum in support of motion for partial summary judgement; Exhibits 1-3; COS
07720-Jun-16LonoMotion for refund of filing fee; Memorandum in support of motion for refund of filing fee; COS
07620-Jun-16LonoDeclaration of Frank Tamehameha Kamehaloha Anuumealani Nobriga re: Appointment of Lanny Alan Sinkin as an Officer of the Temple of Lono; COS
07517-Jun-16TIODeclaration of J. Douglas Ing; Exhibits "A" thru "C" and COS
07417-Jun-16Lono Statement of representation; COS (partial)
07313-Jun-16Lee "Exhibits A- J"
07213-Jun-16Lono"Notice: Fee Paid Under Protest;" Exhibits 1 and 2; Declaration of Lanny Alan Sinkin; COS
07113-Jun-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's response to the requests to intervene as a party pursuant to Minute Order No. 7; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit A; COS
07013-Jun-16AnainaPetitioners' memorandum in opposition to TMT's motion to have TMT International Observatory, LLC admitted as a party in the contested case hearing; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "A" - "D;" COS
06913-Jun-16AnainaPetitioners' memorandum in opposition to Perpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to intervene, dated May 16 2016; Declaration of counsel; Exhibit "A;" and COS
06813-Jun-16W FreitasRequest from William K. Freitas to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
06713-Jun-16xRequest from Maile Taualii and Danelle Cooper to be withdrawn as a party from contested case hearing
0669-Jun-1611 Minute OrderMinute Order 11: Order regarding relocation of hearings on motions to intervene
0656-Jun-1610 Minute OrderMinute Order 10: Order regarding hearing /conference room rules and extended coverage; COS
0642-Jun-16C FreitasRequest from Cindy Freitas to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
0633-Jun-1609 Minute OrderMinute Order 9: Order denying Petitioners' motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 4 filed on May 6, 2016 and/or Motion to strike selection process and to disqualify various members and Hearing Officer; COS
0622-Jun-16OCCLCorrespondence from OCCL to Petitioners regarding contested case filing fee, exparte communication, and documents library; copy AG, HO, Sandison, Wurdeman
0611-Jun-16OCCLCombined requests to intervene received by the Department of Land and Natural Resources on May 31, 2016; Updated contact sheet for Petitioners; COS
060xx(duplicate)
05931-May-16KealohaRequest from Brannon Kamahana Kealoha to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05831-May-16xRequest from Joy Keahipuakauikawekiu Mills-Ferren to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05731-May-16VicenteRequest from Dwight J. Vicente to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05631-May-16KilaRequest from Glen Kila to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
0551-Jun-16OCCLCombined requests to intervene received by the Department of Land and Natural Resources between April 8, 2016 and May 31, 2016; Contact sheet for Petitioners; COS
05431-May-16KakaliaRequest from Tiffnie Kakalia to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05331-May-16TabbadaRequest from Stephanie-Malia:Tabbada to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05231-May-16AnainaPetitioners' submissions and positions on record; Exhibit "A"; COS
05131-May-16KanaeleRequest from Kalikolehua Kanaele to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
05028-May-16LonoRequest from Temple of Lono to intervene; Memorandum in support of motion; Declaration of Tahuna Frank Kamehameha Tamealoha Anuumealani Nobriga with exhibits; COS
04927-May-1608 Minute OrderMinute Order 8: Order setting hearings on motions to intervene and 2nd pre-hearing conference; COS (3)
04827-May-16xRequest from Maile Taualii and Danelle Cooper to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
04726-May-16xRequest from Linda Namauu to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
04626-May-16TIOTMT International Observatory, LLC's supplemental memorandum in support of its motion to have TMT International Observatory, LLC admitted as a party in the contested case hearing, filed April 8, 2016; COS
04526-May-16OCCLAmano fifth supplemental disclosure; COS
04426-May-1607 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 7: Order regarding 1st prehearing conference and Amano fourth supplemental disclosure; COS
04325-May-16UHHThe University of Hawaii at Hilo's statement of position on Petitioners' motion for reconsideration of minute order no. 4, filed on May 6, 2016 and/or motion to strike selection process and to disqualify various members and hearing officer, filed May 13, 2016; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits "1" and "2"; COS
04225-May-16BLNRResponse to Petitioners' objections to Christopher Yuen; COS
04123-May-1606 Minute OrderMinute Order 6: Order setting response date; COS
04023-May-16xRequest from Michelle Cabalse to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03921-May-16LeeRequest from Maelani Lee to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03813-May-16SleightholmRequest from Jennifer Leina'ala Sleightholm to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03713-May-16xRequest from Patricia Ikeda to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03613-May-16xRequest from Eric Hansen to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03513-May-16xRequest from Keahi Tajon to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03416-May-16xRequest from Ricky Cassiday to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03316-May-16PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities, Inc.'s motion to intervene; memorandum in support of motion; declaration of Shadd Keahi Warfield; Declaration of Patrick Leo Kahawaiolaa; Declaration of William H. Brown; Declaration of Richard Ha, Jr., Exhibits "A" and "B"; COS
03216-May-16xRequest from Michael Kumukauoha Lee to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
03113-May-16AnainaPetitioners' motion for reconsideration of Minute Order No. 4, filed on May 6, 2016 and/or motion to strike selection process and to disqualify various members and hearing officer; Memorandum in support of motion; declaration of Richard Naiwieha Wurdeman; Exhibits "A" - "D"; and COS
03013-May-16xRequest from Moses Kealamakia, Jr. to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02913-May-16xRequest from Wilma H. Holi to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02813-May-16xRequest from Ivy McIntosh to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02713-May-16xRequest from Crystal W West to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02612-May-16xRequest from Hālonaikaiopuna Mikala-Jiro Fukutomi to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02512-May-16CamaraRequest from Joseph Kuali`i Lindsey Camara to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02411-May-16KanuhaRequest from C. M. Kaho'okahi Kanuha to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02311-May-16KihoiRequest from Mehana Kihoi to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02212-May-16DeLeonRequest from Richard Maele DeLeon to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02111-May-16xRequest from Ana Nawahine-Kahoopii to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
02012-May-16xRequest from Harry Fergestrom to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
01912-May-16xRequest from Waiala Ahn to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
01812-May-16xRequest from Edward Akiona to be admitted as a party to the contested case hearing
0179-May-16HOCorrespondence from Hearing Officer to counsel regarding pre-hearing conference
0169-May-1605 Minute OrderMinute Order 5: Order setting pre-hearing conference; COS
0156-May-16AnainaPetitioners' objections regarding procurement committee and process and committee member / BLNR Board member; Declaration of Counsel; Exhibits "A" - "E"; COS
0146-May-1604 Minute OrderMinute Order 4: Order regarding objections to the selection process, and regarding objections to the Hearing Officer; COS
0132-May-16AnainaPetitioners' responsive and supplemental objections to selection process and to appointment of Hearing Officer made pursuant to Minute Order No. 1, dated March 31, 2016; COS
0122-May-16BLNRNotice of filing of disclosures by BLNR Chairperson Case and Board Member Yuen; Exhibits 1 and 2; COS
01129-Apr-1603 Minute OrderMinute Order 3: Order setting deadlines for responses to Hearing Officer's supplemental disclosures; COS
01027-Apr-16BLNRNotice of Filing of Hearing Officer's third supplemental disclosure, dated April 25, 2016; Exhibit 4; COS
00922-Apr-16BLNRNotice of Filing of Hearing Officer's second supplemental disclosure, dated April 29, 2016; Exhibit 3; COS
000 R-825-Feb-11OCCLExhibits for OCCL staff report regarding Conservation District Use Application HA-3568 for theThirty Meter Telescope
00821-Apr-16UHHApplicant's response to Petitioners' objections to selection process and to appointment of Hearing Officer made pursuant to Minute Order No. 1, dated March 31, 2016, filed on April 15, 2006; copy Wurdeman
000 R-725-Feb-11OCCLOCCL staff report regarding Conservation District Use Application HA-3568 for theThirty Meter Telescope
00719-Apr-16OCCLNotices regarding ex parte communication to members of the Land Board, Watanabe Ing LLP, Carlsmith Ball LLP, Wurdeman; copy Amano
000 R-619-May-10GovernorAcceptance Letter of the Governor to the Chancellor, University of Hawaii at Hilo Regarding Mitigation Measures in the Final Environmental Assessment for the Thirty Meter Telescope Observatory on Mauna Kea, Island of Hawaii
00615-Apr-16UHHApplicant's response to Minute Orders Nos. 1 and 2; Exhibits 1-5; Copy Wurdeman
000 R-58-May-10UHHThirty Meter Telescope (TMT) Project Chapter 343 Final Environmental Impact Statement Volume 3 - Appendices
00515-Apr-16AnainaPetitioners' objections to selection process and to appointment of Hearing Officer made pursuant to Minute Order No. 1, dated March 31, 2016; Declaration of counsel; Exhibits 'A' - 'G'; and COS
000 R-48-May-10UHHThirty Meter Telescope (TMT) Project Chapter 343 Final Environmental Impact Statement Volume 2
0048-Apr-16BLNRNotice of filing of Hearing Officer's supplemental disclosure; Exhibit 2; COS
000 R-38-May-10UHHThirty Meter Telescope (TMT) Project Chapter 343 Final Environmental Impact Statement Volume 1
0038-Apr-1602 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 2: Order delegating the conduct of the contested case hearing to a hearing officer, and confirming that the chairperson was authorized to engage the services of a hearing officer; COS
000 R-28-May-10UHHThirty Meter Telescope (TMT) Project Chapter 343 Final EIS summary Sheet
0028-Apr-16TIOMotion to have TMT International Observatory, LLC admitted as a party in the contested case hearing; memorandum in support of motion; COS
000 R-12-Sep-10UHHConservation District Use Application for the Thirty Meter Telescope Project from the Univesity of Hawaii at Hilo
00131-Mar-1601 Minute OrderMinute Order No. 1: Notice of selection of Riki May Amano as Hearing Officer on subject contested case; Exhibit 1; COS

 

Parties to Contested Case HA-16-02

AbbreviatedFull Counsel / Representative
HOHearing Officer Judge Riki May Amano (ret.)
AnainaMauna Kea Anaina Hou, Clarence Kukauakahi Ching, Flores-Case ‘Ohana, Deborah J. Ward, Paul K. Neves, and Kahea: The Environmental AllianceRichard N. Wurdeman
BLNRBoard of Land and Natural ResourcesJulie China, Deputy Attorney General
C FreitasCindy Freitaspro se
CamaraJoseph Kualii Lindsey Camarapro se
DeLeonRichard L. Maele DeLeon(withdrew)
FergerstromHarry Fergerstrompro se
Flores-CaseFlores-Case OhanaKalani Flores, Pualani Case (pro se)
KAHEAKahea: The Environmental AllianceYuklin Aluli, Dexter Kaiama
KakaliaTiffnie Kakaliapro se
KanaeleAli`i Sir Kalikolehua Kanaelepro se
KanuhaC. M. Kaho'okahi Kanuhapro se
KealohaBrannon Kamahana Kealohapro se
KihoiMehana Kihoipro se
KilaGlen Kilapro se
LeeMaelani Lee(withdrew)
LonoThe Temple of LonoLanny Alan Sinkin
MKAHMauna Kea Anaina HouKealoha Pisciotta (pro se)
OCCLOffice of Conservation and Coastal Lands (Custodian of the Records)Michael Cain
PUEOPerpetuating Unique Educational Opportunities Torkildson, Katz, Moore, Hetherington & Harris
SleightholmJennifer Leinaala Sleightholmpro se
TabbadaStephanie-Malia:Tabbadapro se
TIOTMT International Observatory, LLCWatanabe Ing LLP
UHHUniversity of Hawaii at Hilo (applicant)Carlsmith Ball LLP
VicenteDwight J. Vicentepro se
W FreitasWilliam Freitaspro se
WardDeborah Wardpro se
xother (non parties)